AGENDA AND BUSINESS PAPER
To be held on
Monday
28 October 2019
AT 6.00pm
Cnr Baylis and Morrow Streets,
Wagga Wagga NSW 2650
PO Box 20, Wagga Wagga
Phone: 1300 292 442
Fax: 02 6926 9199
Website: www.wagga.nsw.gov.au
NOTICE OF MEETING
In pursuance of the provisions of the Local Government Act, 1993 and the Regulations there under, notice is hereby given that an Ordinary Meeting of the Council of the City of Wagga Wagga will be held in the Council Chamber, Civic Centre, Corner Baylis and Morrow Streets, Wagga Wagga, on Monday 28 October 2019 at 6.00pm.
Council live streams video and audio of Council meetings. Members of the public are advised that their voice and/or image may form part of the webcast.

Mr Peter Thompson
General Manager
WAGGA WAGGA CITY COUNCILLORS
|
Mayor Councillor Greg Conkey OAM |
Deputy Mayor Councillor Dallas Tout |
Councillor Yvonne Braid |
Councillor Paul Funnell |
|
Councillor Dan Hayes |
Councillor Vanessa Keenan |
Councillor Rod Kendall |
Councillor Tim Koschel |
|
Councillor Kerry Pascoe |
|
|
|
QUORUM
The quorum for a meeting of the Council is a majority of the Councillors of the Council who hold office for the time being who are eligible to vote at the meeting.
COUNCIL MEETING ROOM

Reports submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council to be held on Monday 28 October 2019.
Ordinary Meeting of Council AGENDA AND BUSINESS PAPER
Monday 28 October 2019
CLAUSE PRECIS PAGE
PRAYER 3
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COUNTRY 3
APOLOGIES 3
CONFIRMATIONS OF MINUTES 3
CM-1 ORDINARY COUNCIL MEETING - 8 OCTOBER 2019
DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST 3
Motions Of Which Due Notice Has Been Given
NOM-1 NOTICE OF MOTION - LAKE ALBERT 4
NOM-2 NOTICE OF MOTION - REVIEW OF BOURKE STREET 6
NOM-3 NOTICE OF MOTION - VOTE OF NO CONFIDENCE IN COUNCILLOR KEENAN 8
NOM-4 NOTICE OF MOTION - REPRESENTING THE INTERESTS OF COUNCIL AT CONFERENCES 10
Reports from Staff
RP-1 DA18/0408 - Pig Farm (Intensive Livestock Agriculture) – 15,000 Standard Pig Unit Facility and associated infrastructure 12
RP-2 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2018/19 17
RP-3 Financial Performance Report as at 30 September 2019 28
RP-4 LAKE ALBERT ROAD REHABILITATION STAGE 2 - REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL FUNDING 67
RP-5 DRAFT NEW POLICY - POL118 - ROADSIDE MEMORIALS POLICY 70
RP-6 Official invitation to attend 4th Kunming International Sister City Seminar 77
RP-7 Douglas Aerospace Working Group 82
RP-8 COUNCIL MEETING DATES JANUARY 2020 to DECEMBER 2020 87
RP-9 Mobile Food Vendor - Policy & Fee Exhibition 89
RP-10 DRAFT COMPLAINT HANDLING POLICY (POL 103) 104
RP-11 Response to Questions/Business with Notice 120
Committee Minutes
M-1 Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee Meeting Minutes 10 October 2019 122
M-2 TRAFFIC COMMITTEE - 12 SEPTEMBER 2019 130
M-3 FLOODPLAIN RISK MANAGEMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE - MINUTES - 1 OCTOBER 2019 141
QUESTIONS/BUSINESS WITH NOTICE 146
Confidential Reports
CONF-1 RFT2019-33 STRENGTHENING AND WIDENING EUNONY BRIDGE 147
CONF-2 BOTANIC GARDENS RESTAURANT AND CAFE LEASE 148
CONF-3 Lake Albert Blue Green Algae Remediation (Extension of Trial) 149
CONF-4 RFT2020-08 ROAD STABILISATION PRODUCTS SUPPLY 150
CONF-5 EXHIBITION CENTRE IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS 151
PRAYER
Confirmation of Minutes
CM-1 ORDINARY COUNCIL MEETING - 8 OCTOBER 2019
|
That the Minutes of the proceedings of the Ordinary Council Meeting held on 8 October 2019 be confirmed as a true and accurate record.
|
|
1⇩. |
Ordinary Council Meeting Minutes - 8 October 2019 |
152 |
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
NOM-1 |
Motions Of Which Due Notice Has Been Given
NOM-1 NOTICE OF MOTION - LAKE ALBERT
Author: Councillor Tim Koschel
|
Summary: |
Lake Albert is an important asset to the City of Wagga Wagga. With Staff currently undertaking the development of a new Plan of Management for Lake Albert a final report on the outcomes of the previous plan will inform Councillors and the Community of the actions undertaken and their impact. |
|
That Council: a receive a report on the outcomes of the Lake Albert Management Plan that details all actions and investigations undertaken in response to the plan’s recommendations; and b receive an update on the development of the new Lake Albert Plan of Management and the proposed timeline for implementation c create a priority list of projects which can be included in Council’s future advocacy plan |
Report
Lake Albert is an important asset to the City of Wagga Wagga that has in recent times been impacted by low water levels and blue green algae outbreaks. Despite this it remains a valued community recreational and environmental asset for the City
Council (often in partnership with Community organisations) have undertaken and continue to undertake investigations and actions in regard to addressing the low water level and algae issues whilst also improving the usability and amenity of the Lake Albert precinct.
With Staff currently undertaking the development of a new Plan of Management for Lake Albert a final report to Council on the outcomes of the previous plan will inform Councillors and the Community of the actions and investigations undertaken and their impact.
Financial Implications
N/A
Policy and Legislation
Wagga Wagga City Council Code of Meeting Practice
Link to Strategic Plan
The Environment
Objective: Create and maintain a functional, attractive and health promoting built environment
Outcome: We look after and maintain our community assets
Risk Management Issues for Council
N/A
Internal / External Consultation
N/A
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
NOM-2 |
NOM-2 NOTICE OF MOTION - REVIEW OF BOURKE STREET
Author: Councillor Dan Hayes
|
Summary: |
The purpose of this Notice of Motion is for Council to consider improvements for Bourke Street specifically between Fernleigh Road and Red Hill Road. |
|
That Council receive a report that provides: a an overview of all current projects being explored for Bourke Street b options to improve the safety and amenity of the road for pedestrians and drivers |
Report
Different concerns and complaints have been raised about Bourke Street specifically between Red Hill Road and Fernleigh Road. While many of these concerns have been actioned or currently being reviewed there remains a significant issue of the safety and amenity of one the city’s key roads. This is due to the confluence of issues such as:
· four lanes of traffic
· pedestrian crossings
· lighting
· school zones
· trees blocking sight of drivers
· shopping centre
A report outlining the current projects being explored, as well as identifying issues for pedestrians and drivers, and the opportunities and restraints of relevant traffic rules and guidelines, will allow Council and the community to consider significant improvements and associated costs.
Financial Implications
N/A
Policy and Legislation
Wagga Wagga City Council Code of Meeting Practice
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Leadership and Collaboration
Objective: We have strong leadership
Outcome: We have leaders that represent us
Risk Management Issues for Council
N/A
Internal / External Consultation
N/A
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
NOM-3 |
NOM-3 NOTICE OF MOTION - VOTE OF NO CONFIDENCE IN COUNCILLOR KEENAN
Author: Councillor Tim Koschel
|
Summary: |
Elected Council representatives should represent the interests of Wagga Wagga City Council (Council) when attending and voting at state and federal conferences. Councillor Keenan has refused to disclose the way in which she voted during a recent ratepayer paid conference and I believe these actions leave no confidence in Councillor Keenan representing Council. |
|
That Council conduct a vote of no confidence in Councillor Vanessa Keenan. |
Report
The role of Councillors is to represent the interests of the City of Wagga Wagga and the decisions made by Council, whether you support the decision or not.
Councillor Keenan was elected by the Councillors to represent Council at the recent Local Government NSW conference. This trip was funded by ratepayers for all elected Councillors to represent Wagga Wagga and the decisions made by the elected body, not for individual Councillors to vote based on personal interests or political parties they are aligned with.
Councillor Keenan has refused to disclose the way in which she voted during a ratepayer paid conference. The way Councillors vote when representing the Council should be completely transparent and be reflective of past decisions / strategic directions set by the elected body (as resolved).
I believe these actions leave no confidence in Councillor Keenan representing Council.
Financial Implications
N/A
Policy and Legislation
Wagga Wagga Code of Meeting Practice
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Leadership and Collaboration
Objective: We have strong leadership
Outcome: We are accountable and transparent
Risk Management Issues for Council
N/A
Internal / External Consultation
N/A
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
NOM-4 |
NOM-4 NOTICE OF MOTION - REPRESENTING THE INTERESTS OF COUNCIL AT CONFERENCES
Author: Councillor Tim Koschel
|
Summary: |
The purpose of this notice of motion is for Council to develop a policy for sending elected Councillors to all conferences including state and national conferences. |
|
That Council: a receive a report with a draft policy as outlined in the body of this report b request that the report be completed and implemented before nominations are called for the next conference |
Report
The purpose of this notice of motion is for Council to develop a new policy (or update an existing policy) for sending elected Councillors to all conferences, including state and national conferences. The policy is to include the below, and be completed and implemented by the time the nominations are called for the next conference.
a Elected Council representatives are required to represent the interest of Wagga Wagga City Council (Council) and endorse decisions made by elected members in previous Council meetings (If elected Council representative has voting rights)
b Councillors are not to represent self-interests or those expressed by political parties that they are members of (If elected Council representative has voting rights)
c All elected members need to report back to Council in an open manner about the way in which they voted in the conference as they are representing the entire elected body
d Any elected Councillor who represents themselves and not the interests of Council, or refuses to disclose the way they voted will exclude themselves from being nominated to attend futures conference during current term of Council
Financial Implications
N/A
Policy and Legislation
Wagga Wagga Code of Meeting Practice
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Leadership and Collaboration
Objective: We have strong leadership
Outcome: We have leaders that represent us
Risk Management Issues for Council
Without a policy in place, there is a risk of Councillors representing themselves and not the interests of the whole Council when attending conferences.
Internal / External Consultation
N/A
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
RP-1 |
RP-1 DA18/0408 - Pig Farm (Intensive Livestock Agriculture) – 15,000 Standard Pig Unit Facility and associated infrastructure
Author: Cameron Collins
General Manager: Peter Thompson
|
Summary: |
The report is for a development application and is presented to Council for determination. The application has been referred to Council under Section 1.10 of the Wagga Wagga Development Control Plan 2010 (WWDCP) as the number of submissions in the form of objections received is more than 10. |
|
That Council approve DA18/0408 for a pig farm (intensive livestock agriculture) incorporating a 15,000 standard pig unit facility and associated infrastructure at 240 Flanagans Road, Matong, Lots 48, 51 & 54 DP 750854 and Lot 1 DP 1085420 subject to conditions outlined in the Section 4.15 assessment report for DA18/0408. |
Development Application Details
|
Applicant |
Pig Improvement Company Australia Pty Ltd (PICA) |
|
Owner |
Sunpork Pty Ltd
Directors: Donald Clarendon Taylor John Beauchamp Cameron Brian John McLean Kenneth Beauchamp Cameron Simon Alexander Hall Pamela Anne McLean Enzo Allara Robert John van Barneveld David Roger Alexander Hall
Secretary: Geoffrey Miller
|
|
Development Cost |
$9,000,000 |
|
Development Description |
Pig Farm (Intensive Livestock Agriculture) – 15,000 Standard Pig Unit Facility and associated infrastructure |
Report
Key Issues
The proposal is ‘designated development’ under the EP&A Act because of the size of the piggery. As ‘designated’ development, the application is accompanied by an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) prepared in accordance with the Planning Secretary’s Environmental Assessment Requirements (SEAR’s). The EIS addresses the potential impacts of the piggery including waste, odour, noise and traffic
The proposal is ‘integrated development’ because it also requires a license under the NSW Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997. General Terms of Approval have been issued by the NSW Environment Protection Authority.
Public notification of the application resulted in the receipt of a significant number of public submissions in the form of objections.
The site adjoins both the Coolamon Shire LGA and the Narrandera Shire LGA. Submissions received from both Council’s did not result in any significant concerns.
All key issues are addressed within the attached Section 4.15 assessment report.
Assessment
The application has been referred to relevant government agencies and publicly exhibited in accordance with the requirements for designated development. The application attracted a significant number of objections from across the country mostly on the grounds that the operation of indoor piggeries in general is tantamount to animal cruelty and that the facility presents as an unacceptable environmental risk. No objections were received from government agencies and there was a small number of local submissions in support of the proposal.
The application has been assessed against the requirements of Section 4.15 of the EP&A Act (see attached assessment report), that sets out the matters a consent authority (in this case Wagga Wagga City Council) must consider development applications against. In particular, consideration has been given to the environmental impacts of the piggery and the proposed means of mitigating any detrimental impacts.
As detailed in the attached Section 4.15 assessment report, it is concluded there are no justifiable grounds for refusing the application. Consequently, the application is recommended for approval subject to conditions imposed under Section 4.17 of the EP&A Act.
Reasons for Approval
The development is consistent with the aims, objectives and provisions of both the Wagga Wagga Local Environmental Plan 2010, Wagga Wagga Development Control Plan 2010 and relevant state planning policies.
The application has been assessed against the heads of consideration under Section 4.15 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 and deemed to be satisfactory with regard to the impacts of the development and the proposed means of mitigating against the impacts.
General Terms of Approval have been issued by the Environment Protection Authority (EPA) with respect to an Environmental Protection License under the Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997.
Site Location
The site for the piggery is centrally located on a large rural land parcel comprised of four lots with a total area of 604 hectares. The land has frontage to Flanagans Road with the proposed access being approximately 2.5 kilometres north of its intersection with Old Narrandera Road. The subject land is approximately 10 kilometres to the south west of Matong, 25 kilometres east of Narrandera and 55 kilometres west of Wagga Wagga. It abuts the Narrandera Shire to the west and Coolamon Shire to the north east.

Financial Implications
N/A
Policy
N/A
Link to Strategic Plan
The Environment
Objective: We plan for the growth of the city
Outcome: We have sustainable urban development
Risk Management Issues for Council
Refusal of the application may result in an appeal process in the Land and Environment Court which will have to be defended by Council. The reasons for refusal will have to be justified and withstand scrutiny and cross examination in Court.
Approval is not considered to raise risk management issues for Council as the proposed development is generally consistent with the relevant provisions of the Wagga Wagga Local Environmental Plan 2010 and the Wagga Wagga Development Control Plan 2010.
Internal / External Consultation
Full details of consultation are provided within the attached Section 4.15 assessment report.
With regard to the attached redacted public submissions please note that this contains:
· 7 submissions in support (all local).
· 4 objections from adjoining or nearby landowners/occupants.
· 10 individual and unique objections from farther afield.
· 8 objections from organisations (including political parties).
· 1 copy of the133 individual objections based on a 16-page pro forma submission (or a variation thereof).
· 1 copy of the written content of 2 petitions against the development:
o an on-line petition hosted by Animal Liberation, objecting to the application containing more than 3,500 claimed signatories (at the time of drafting this report).
o an on-line petition hosted by Say No To Pig Improvement Company’s Expansion In Matong objecting to the application and containing more than 5,500 claimed signatories (at the time of drafting this report).
· A Councillor Workshop was held on Monday 21 October 2019 to provide clarification on a range of matters within the report. A copy of the information paper supplied to Councillors including answers provided is attached to this report.
A Councillor workshop was held on 21 October 2019, with the following Councillors in attendance:
· Councillor Braid
· Councillor Conkey
· Councillor Funnell
· Councillor Hayes
· Councillor Keenan
· Councillor Kendall
· Councillor Pascoe
·
Councillor
Tout
|
|
|
Media |
Community Engagement |
Digital |
|||||||||||||
|
Rates notices insert |
Direct mail |
Letterbox drop |
Council news story |
Council News advert |
Media releases |
TV/radio advertising |
One-on-one meetings |
Your Say website |
Community meetings |
Stakeholder workshops |
Drop-in sessions |
Surveys and feedback forms |
Social media |
Email newsletters |
Website |
Digital advertising |
|
|
TIER |
|||||||||||||||||
|
Consult |
|
x |
|
x |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
x |
|
||||
|
Involve |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||||||
|
Collaborate |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1⇨. |
DA18-0408 - Environmental Impact Statement - Provided under separate cover |
|
|
2⇨. |
DA18-0408 - Site Plans - Provided under separate cover |
|
|
3⇨. |
DA18/0408 - Building Plans - Provided under separate cover |
|
|
4⇨. |
DA18/0408 - Government Submissions - Provided under separate cover |
|
|
5⇨. |
DA18-0408 - Redacted Public Submissions - Provided under separate cover |
|
|
6⇨. |
DA18-0408 - Applicant's Response to Government Submissions - Provided under separate cover |
|
|
7⇨. |
DA18-0408 - Applicant's Response to Public Submissions - Provided under separate cover |
|
|
8⇨. |
DA18-0408 - Section 4.15 Assessment Report - Provided under separate cover |
|
|
9⇨. |
DA18-0408 - Councillor Briefing Paper - Provided under separate cover |
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019. RP-2
RP-2 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2018/19
Author: Carolyn Rodney
Director: Natalie Te Pohe
|
Analysis: |
The 2018/19 Financial Statements have been completed by Council staff and have recently been audited by the NSW Audit Office. |
|
That Council: a note the comments from the Audit, Risk & Improvement Committee regarding the 2018/19 Financial Statements b approve the signing of the 2018/19 Financial Statements pursuant to Section 413 (2)(c) of the Local Government Act 1993 c approve the closing balances of the Restricted Assets (Reserves) as at 30 June 2019 as detailed in Note 6 (c) - Cash & Investments d receive a presentation from the NSW Audit Office on the audited financial reports and auditors report at the 25 November 2019 Council Meeting, pursuant to Section 418(1) and provide public notice accordingly |
Report
The 2018/19 Annual Financial Statements have been prepared and Council’s external auditors, NSW Audit Office have completed their audit. It is a requirement of the Local Government Act 1993 that Council prepare a statement on the General Purpose and Special Purpose Financial Reports prior to sign off by the auditor. These statements must be signed by the Mayor, one Councillor, the General Manager and the Responsible Accounting Officer.
This statement is required to be signed and included in the Financial Statements prior to the auditor providing the final audit reports. The Financial Statements together with the auditors’ reports must be forwarded to the Department of Planning, Industry and Environment (formerly the Office of Local Government) by 31 October 2019.
The 2018/19 financial statements were presented to the Audit, Risk & Improvement Committee (ARIC) at its meeting on 10 October 2019. The report from the Chairperson is included in the Committee meetings minutes in a separate report to this meeting, with an extract provided below for Councillors’ information:
Extract from the Report from the ARIC Chairperson:
RP4 and 5: Financial Statements
Preparation of financial statements is the responsibility of management and the Council, not the external auditors or the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee.
The Committee’s responsibility is to make an advisory judgement on the financial statements and the systems and procedures used to create them.
The Director Finance advised the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee that the external audit of the 2018/2019 financial statements has been completed successfully and that there were no contentious financial reporting matters or material changes to be reported.
The Committee reviewed the key aspects of the financial statements and sought clarification of a number of issues. Matters discussed included:
· Changes to accounting standards
· Explanation of key movements in the net operating result for the year
· RFS assets and Crown Lands
· Financial performance indicators
· Asset valuation and impairment
· Contingent assets and liabilities
· Working capital, and
· Events since balance date.
As a result of these discussions and internal audit coverage during the year and past periods, the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee reached the conclusion that, in accordance with its charter:
· it was satisfied that the annual financial statements for the year ended 30 June 2019 comply with applicable Australian accounting standards and are supported by appropriate management sign-off on the statements and Council’s systems of internal controls;
· the proposed external audit opinion was supported by appropriate coverage and management had taken appropriate action on all material audit recommendations to date; and
· ·there were no other contentious financial reporting matters that the Committee considered should be reported to Council.
Council’s external auditors informed the Committee that (subject to final clearance of minor changes to the statements) the external audit report on the financial statements would be unqualified and that Council’s financial position is ‘sound’.
They also advised that they found no accounting policies or application of policies, other than was already disclosed in the statements, that needed to be brought to the attention of the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee.
The external auditors noted that the working papers and the level of co-operation provided during the audit were both professional and of high standard.
Marg Nicholls
Chair
Wagga Wagga City Council Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee
2018/19 Financial Overview
The 2018/19 draft financial statements show total income from continuing operations of $154.9M and total expenses from continuing operations of $127.4M, resulting in a preliminary net operating surplus of $27.5M (including capital grants and contributions). The 2017/18 financial year resulted in a net operating surplus of $22.1M. The main difference in the increased net result was attributable to an increase in capital grants and contributions and rates and annual charges recognised during 2018/19.
Extract from the 2018/19 Draft Financial Statements – Income Statement:

For the 2018/19 financial year, Council met the benchmark for four (4) of the six (6) performance indicators outlined within the financial statements. This is a decrease from the five (5) met in 2017/18. Below is an extract of the performance indicators from the draft 2018/19 financial statements.
Extract from the 2018/19 Draft Financial Statements – Statement of performance measures:


As a result of Council undertaking loan refinancing for a number of existing loans during 2018/19, the Debt service cover ratio took a one-off hit – reducing from 4.79x in 2017/18 to 1.54x in 2018/19. This refinancing will result in a better overall result for Council of approximately $0.239M over the next 6-8 years. If the refinancing did not occur, the Debt service cover ratio would have been 3.75x and achieving the recommended benchmark.
As of 30 June 2019, Council held $33.1M in internal reserves, a decrease of $3.7M on the previous year. The major internally restricted reserves Council holds are:
|
Reserve Name |
30 June 2019 Balance |
30 June 2018 Balance |
Increase/ (Decrease) from prior year* |
|
Plant and Vehicle Replacement |
$3.550M |
$3.935M |
($0.385M) |
|
Employees Leave Entitlements |
$3.585M |
$3.323M |
$0.262M |
|
Fit for the Future |
$1.785M |
$5.340M |
($3.555M) |
|
Grant Commission |
$5.256M |
$5.199M |
$0.057M |
*Notes on Increases/(Decreases):
· Plant and Vehicle Replacement Reserve – Council experienced delays in fulfilling their plant replacement program during the 2016/17 financial year and were able to catch up some of the backlog in replacement during both the 2017/18 and 2018/19 financial years.
· Fit for the Future Reserve – an additional $1.36M has been transferred to this Reserve during 2018/19, with a one-off transfer of funding from the Reserve of ($4.55M) that is proposed to be paid back to this Reserve from the Sewer fund pending the Minister for Local Government’s approval of this internal loan. These transfers have resulted in a reduced closing balance of $1.785M at 30 June 2019.
· Grant Commission Reserve – $5.256M received for a 50% prepayment of the Financial Assistance Grant relating to the 2019/20 financial year. This prepayment commenced in the 2016/17 financial year.
· Additional Reserve transfers – following a number of years of uncommitted operating surplus results to budget, Council staff have allocated an additional $2.2M in Reserve transfers including $1M for the Fit for the Future Reserve, $0.500M for the Economic Development Reserve, $0.300M for the Bridge Replacement Reserve, $0.200M for the Information Services Reserve and $0.100M each for the Sporting Event Attraction and Sporting Event Operations Reserves. These amounts held in Reserve will be utilised this financial year or in future financial years, with Council adoption required to transfer funds out of these Reserves when they are proposed to be utilised.
A copy of the Draft Financial Statements are attached to this report.
Update to Report on Infrastructure Assets (previously named Special Schedule 7) – unaudited report. Post ARIC meeting adjustment
After completion of the draft financial statements and after the ARIC meeting, staff identified that the original Report on Infrastructure Assets (previously Special Schedule 7) workpapers for Roads assets (sealed and unsealed) were calculated at an asset level, and not at a component level.
Wagga’s sealed roads are componentised into 4 levels – surface, pavement base, pavement sub-base and formation; with unsealed roads componentised into two levels – pavement base and formation.
The amended calculation results in a reduction to the roads backlog figure from $136.8M to $100.2M for 2018/19 and was $121.3M for 2017/18. This reduction is reflective of the work carried out during the 2018/19 financial year, along with updates to the road network condition data.
|
|
2017/18 Estimated cost to bring assets to satisfactory standard $’000 |
PREVIOUS DRAFT STATEMENTS Estimated cost to bring assets to satisfactory standard $’000 |
REVISED Estimated cost to bring assets to satisfactory standard
$’000 |
|
Sealed Roads |
$89,455 |
$100,606 |
$74,536 |
|
Unsealed Roads |
$31,859 |
$36,209 |
$25,660 |
|
Subtotal Roads |
$121,314 |
$136,815 |
$100,196 |
The Report on Infrastructure Assets statement is an unaudited statement. Council staff have advised the NSW Audit Office of this adjustment, and they have no issues with this proposed late change, due to the report falling outside of their audit.
An email has been sent to all ARIC committee members advising them of the adjustment to the draft financial statements.
Financial Implications
Whilst this report and associated attachments show Council’s financial performance and position for the 2018/19 financial year, the adoption of this report by the Council has no financial implications.
Policy and Legislation
Local Government Act 1993
Sections: 413 - Preparation of Financial Reports
418 - Public notice to be given of presentation of financial reports
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Leadership and Collaboration
Objective: We have strong leadership
Outcome: We are accountable and transparent
Risk Management Issues for Council
The NSW Audit Office have provided Council with a final Management Letter which has identified four (4) issues with three (3) rated as Low and one (1) rated as Moderate. Council officers will undertake the actions that have been identified in each of the Management Responses.
Internal / External Consultation
The Council’s Community Engagement Strategy and IAP2 considers the community to be “any individual or group of individuals, organisation or political entity with an interest in the outcome of a decision….”
Council’s external auditors, NSW Audit Office have liaised with Council’s Finance division, along with presenting the results to the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee on 10 October, and to Councillors at a workshop held on 21 October with the following Councillors in attendance:
· Mayor Councillor Greg Conkey OAM
· Deputy Mayor Councillor Dallas Tout
· Councillor Yvonne Braid
· Councillor Paul Funnell
· Councillor Dan Hayes
· Councillor Vanessa Keenan
· Councillor Rod Kendall
· Councillor Kerry Pascoe
· Councillor Tim Koschel
|
|
|
Media |
Community Engagement |
Digital |
|||||||||||||
|
Rates notices insert |
Direct mail |
Letterbox drop |
Council news story |
Council News advert |
Media releases |
TV/radio advertising |
One-on-one meetings |
Your Say website |
Community meetings |
Stakeholder workshops |
Drop-in sessions |
Surveys and feedback forms |
Social media |
Email newsletters |
Website |
Digital advertising |
|
|
TIER |
|||||||||||||||||
|
Consult |
|
|
|
X |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
X |
|
||||
|
Involve |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||||||
|
Collaborate |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1⇨. |
2018/19 Draft Financial Statements - Provided under separate cover |
|
|
2⇩. |
2018/19 General Purpose Financial Statements - Statement by Councillors and Management |
|
|
3⇩. |
2018/19 Special Purpose Financial Statements - Statement by Councillors and Management |
|
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
RP-3 |
RP-3 Financial Performance Report as at 30 September 2019
Author: Carolyn Rodney
Director: Natalie Te Pohe
|
Summary: |
This report is for Council to consider and approve the proposed 2019/20 budget variations required to manage the 2019/20 budget and Long Term Financial Plan, and details Council’s external investments and performance as at 30 September 2019.
This report also presents the financial assistance requests Council has received over the past month. |
|
That Council: a approve the proposed 2019/20 budget variations for the month ended 30 September 2019 and note the balanced budget position as presented in this report b in accordance with Section 356 of the Local Government Act, provide financial assistance to the following: i Wagga Wagga Local Aboriginal Education Consultative Group (WLAECG) $850.00 (Request 1) ii Gunni Thakun Cultural Association $196.00 (Request 2) iii Climate Rescue of Wagga Inc. (CROW) $160.00 (Request 3) iv NSW Sports Federation Inc (Sport NSW) $348.00 (Request 4) v Wagga Wagga Pink Stumps Committee $1,077.00 (Request 5) vi Wagga Autism Support Group $90.00 (Request 6) vii Riverina Medical & Dental & Dental Aboriginal Corporation $95.00 (Request 7) viii Multicultural Council of Wagga Wagga Inc $1,800.00 (Request 8) ix Wagga Inter Church Council $2,200.00 plus provide further financial assistance by covering the cost of additional general waste and recycling bins required for the “Christmas Carols in the Park 2019” event (Request 9) x Vigil at Wagga Victory Memorial Gardens $95.00 (Request 10) xi Tarcutta Transport and Farming Museum $873.12 (Request 11) c rescind the 2019/20 contribution to Kurrajong Waratah of $2,200 for the 2019 “Christmas Spectacular” as this event will not be staged in 2019 by Kurrajong Waratah and was originally included in the adopted 2019/20 Combined Delivery Program and Operational Plan (Minute No 19/212 from the 24 June 2019 Council Officers Report RP-1) d note the Responsible Accounting Officer’s reports, in accordance with the Local Government (General) Regulation 2005 (Part 9 Division 3: Clause 203) that the financial position of Council is satisfactory having regard to the original estimates of income and expenditure and the recommendations made above e note the details of the external investments as at 30 September 2019 in accordance with section 625 of the Local Government Act 1993 |
Report
Wagga Wagga City Council (Council) forecasts a balanced budget position as at 30 September 2019. Proposed budget variations are detailed in this report for Council’s consideration and adoption.
Council has experienced a negative monthly investment performance for the month of September, when compared to budget. This is mainly due to a negative movement for Council’s Floating Rate Note portfolio.
Key Performance Indicators

OPERATING INCOME
Total operating income is 24% of approved budget, which is on budget for the end of September (this percentage excludes capital grants and contributions). An adjustment has been made to reflect the levy of rates that occurred at the start of the financial year. Excluding this adjustment, operating income received is 69%.
OPERATING EXPENSES
Total operating expenditure is 27% of approved budget and is tracking slightly higher than the budget for the full financial year.
CAPITAL INCOME
Total capital income is 4% of approved budget. It is important to note that the actual income from capital is influenced by the timing of the receipt of capital grants and contributions relating to projects. This income also includes the sale of property, plant and equipment.
CAPITAL EXPENDITURE
Total capital expenditure including commitments is 17% of approved budget.
CURRENT LONG TERM FINANCIAL PLAN – PROJECTED SURPLUS/ (DEFICIT) BUDGET POSITION

|
WAGGA WAGGA
CITY COUNCIL |
|||||||
|
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT |
|||||||
|
|
ORIGINAL |
BUDGET ADJ |
APPROVED BUDGET |
YTD ACTUAL EXCL COMMT'S 2019/20 |
COMMT'S 2019/20 |
YTD ACTUAL + COMMT'S |
YTD % OF BUD |
|
Revenue |
|||||||
|
Rates & Annual Charges |
(69,736,893) |
0 |
(69,736,893) |
(17,166,229) |
0 |
(17,166,229) |
25% |
|
User Charges & Fees |
(28,440,057) |
(39,500) |
(28,479,557) |
(5,967,084) |
0 |
(5,967,084) |
21% |
|
Interest & Investment Revenue |
(3,774,001) |
0 |
(3,774,001) |
(955,070) |
0 |
(955,070) |
25% |
|
Other Revenues |
(3,053,633) |
(11,100) |
(3,064,733) |
(1,069,157) |
0 |
(1,069,157) |
35% |
|
Operating Grants & Contributions |
(14,280,296) |
4,941,432 |
(9,338,864) |
(2,370,641) |
0 |
(2,370,641) |
25% |
|
Capital Grants & Contributions |
(56,263,733) |
1,392,770 |
(54,870,963) |
(2,227,826) |
0 |
(2,227,826) |
4% |
|
Total Revenue |
(175,548,613) |
6,283,603 |
(169,265,011) |
(29,756,008) |
0 |
(29,756,008) |
18% |
|
|
|||||||
|
Expenses
|
|||||||
|
Employee Benefits & On-Costs |
46,012,119 |
61,444 |
46,073,563 |
12,087,797 |
121,430 |
12,209,227 |
26% |
|
Borrowing Costs |
3,587,823 |
0 |
3,587,823 |
811,679 |
0 |
811,679 |
23% |
|
Materials & Contracts |
32,357,210 |
5,452,573 |
37,809,784 |
7,604,095 |
3,639,007 |
11,243,101 |
30% |
|
Depreciation & Amortisation |
34,843,073 |
0 |
34,843,073 |
8,710,768 |
0 |
8,710,768 |
25% |
|
Other Expenses |
13,015,295 |
158,738 |
13,174,033 |
3,006,025 |
51,514 |
3,057,539 |
23% |
|
Total Expenses |
129,815,520 |
5,672,756 |
135,488,276 |
32,220,363 |
3,811,950 |
36,032,314 |
27% |
|
|
|
||||||
|
Net Operating (Profit)/Loss |
(45,733,093) |
11,956,358 |
(33,776,735) |
2,464,355 |
3,811,950 |
6,276,306 |
|
|
|
|||||||
|
Net Operating (Profit)/Loss before Capital Grants & Contributions |
10,530,640 |
10,563,588 |
21,094,228 |
4,692,182 |
3,811,950 |
8,504,132 |
|
|
|
|||||||
|
Capital / Reserve Movements |
|||||||
|
Capital Exp - Renewals |
34,034,738 |
3,526,409 |
37,561,148 |
5,501,876 |
10,357,086 |
15,858,961 |
42% |
|
Capital Exp - New Projects |
42,696,132 |
3,954,060 |
46,650,191 |
1,420,290 |
3,767,787 |
5,188,077 |
11% |
|
Capital Exp - Project Concepts |
38,364,925 |
824,985 |
39,189,910 |
57,102 |
40,979 |
98,082 |
0% |
|
Loan Repayments |
3,380,744 |
0 |
3,380,744 |
845,186 |
0 |
845,186 |
25% |
|
New Loan Borrowings |
(21,222,532) |
(351,112) |
(21,573,644) |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0% |
|
Sale of Assets |
(1,502,910) |
(1,745,414) |
(3,248,324) |
(258,339) |
(72,250) |
(330,589) |
10% |
|
Net Movements Reserves |
(15,174,931) |
(18,165,287) |
(33,340,217) |
0 |
1,075 |
1,075 |
0% |
|
Total Cap/Res Movements |
80,576,166 |
(11,956,358) |
68,619,808 |
7,566,115 |
14,094,677 |
21,660,793 |
|
|
|
|||||||
|
|
ORIGINAL |
BUDGET ADJ |
APPROVED
BUDGET |
YTD ACTUAL EXCL COMMT'S 2019/20 |
COMMT'S 2019/20 |
YTD ACTUAL +
COMMT'S |
YTD % OF BUD |
|
Net Result after Depreciation |
34,843,073 |
0 |
34,843,073 |
10,030,471 |
17,906,627 |
27,937,098 |
|
|
|
|||||||
|
Add back Depreciation Expense |
34,843,073 |
0 |
34,843,073 |
8,710,768 |
0 |
8,710,768 |
25% |
|
|
|||||||
|
Cash Budget (Surplus)/Deficit |
0 |
0 |
0 |
1,319,703 |
17,906,627 |
19,226,330 |
|
Revised Budget Result - Surplus/(Deficit) |
$’000s |
|
Original 2019/20 Budget Result as adopted by Council Total Budget Variations approved to date Budget Variations for September 2019 |
$0 $0 $0 |
|
Proposed Revised Budget result for 30 September 2019 |
$0 |
The proposed Budget Variations to 30 September 2019 are listed below:
|
Budget Variation |
Amount |
Funding Source |
Net Impact Fav/ (Unfav) |
||||
1 – Community Leadership and Collaboration |
|||||||
|
$25K |
Corporate Applications ($25K)
|
Nil |
|||||
|
Funds are required for the successful implementation of the Procure to Pay Automated Workflow Project. It was identified during the project scoping exercise that a dependant software module requires updating for continued functionality. This $25K additional budget will bring the total project budget up to $220K. |
|
||||||
|
5 – The Environment |
|||||||
|
Edward Street Footpath |
$75K |
Fit for the Future Reserve ($43K) RMS Contribution ($32K) |
Nil |
||||
|
Funds are required for the replacement of 255 metres of footpath along Edward Street, which was removed to allow for the replacement of the water main along this section. RMS have agreed to only pay for the replacement of this footpath to the existing width standard, being 1.2 metres wide. It is suggested to replace the footpath with a 2.5 metre shared path to ensure that the footpath complies with the requirements of the Bolton Park Master Plan. The total project is estimated at $75K with the RMS contributing ($32K) and Council’s proposed funding of ($43K) to be allocated from the Fit for the Future Reserve. |
|
||||||
|
$166K |
Solid Waste Reserve ($166K) |
Nil |
|||||
|
A budget is required for the chipping of green waste at the Gregadoo Waste Management Centre (GWMC). This chipping is performed when a sufficient stockpile is available to warrant the engagement of a contractor. Green waste comprises of green waste delivered by the general public, arborists and contractors over the weighbridge plus pallets and other separated timber. The budget is required on an ongoing basis, indexed at 3% annually in the Long Term Financial Plan. It is proposed to fund this variation from the Solid Waste Reserve. |
|
||||||
|
Excavator Hire at GWMC |
$100K |
Solid Waste Reserve ($100K) |
Nil |
||||
|
Funds are required for the hire of an excavator for usage at GWMC. The excavator is used to load cover material from the stockpile, shredded green waste, crushed concrete into trucks and to assemble crushed material into an efficient stockpile. This will allow a trial period to test the viability of having an excavator at GWMC on a permanent basis. It is proposed to fund this variation from the Solid Waste Reserve. |
|
||||||
|
Replacement Pump Purchase - GWMC |
$35K |
Solid Waste Reserve ($35K) |
|
||||
|
A budget variation is required for the purchase of replacement pumps at GWMC as the previous pumps have proven unreliable. These pumps are designed for leachate, are corrosion resistant and are solar powered. It is proposed to fund the variation from the Solid Waste Reserve. |
|
||||||
|
Asphalt Repair at GWMC |
$48K |
Solid Waste Reserve ($48K) |
Nil |
||||
|
Funds are required for asphalt/hot mix road patching work at GWMC. The works are required to address Work Health and Safety trip hazards at the transfer station due to the deteriorated nature of the bitumen seal. It is proposed to fund the variation from the Solid Waste Reserve. |
|
||||||
|
|
Nil |
||||||
Current Restrictions
|
RESERVES SUMMARY |
|||||
|
30 SEPTEMBER 2019 |
|||||
|
|
CLOSING BALANCE 2018/19 |
ADOPTED RESERVE TRANSFERS 2019/20 |
BUDGET VARIATIONS APPROVED UP TO COUNCIL MEETING 23.09.19 |
PROPOSED CHANGES for Council Resolution |
REVISED BALANCE |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Externally Restricted |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Developer Contributions - Sect 7.11 |
(23,836,289) |
3,427,074 |
720,687 |
|
(19,688,527) |
|
Developer Contributions - Sect 7.12 |
97,487 |
(32,500) |
154,012 |
|
218,999 |
|
Developer Contributions – S/Water DSP S64 |
(6,551,347) |
2,579,329 |
175,899 |
|
(3,796,118) |
|
Sewer Fund |
(31,115,819) |
155,636 |
1,609,011 |
|
(29,351,171) |
|
Solid Waste |
(21,521,767) |
2,164,970 |
463,609 |
348,474 |
(18,544,713) |
|
Specific Purpose Grants |
(4,044,299) |
0 |
4,044,299 |
|
0 |
|
SRV Levee |
(3,853,286) |
(3,211) |
78,000 |
|
(3,778,497) |
|
Stormwater Levy |
(3,699,109) |
2,758,808 |
573,550 |
|
(366,752) |
|
Total Externally Restricted |
(94,524,428) |
11,050,106 |
7,819,068 |
348,474 |
(75,306,780) |
|
|
|
||||
|
Internally Restricted |
|
||||
|
Airport |
(442,321) |
(522,440) |
6,594 |
(958,166) |
|
|
Art Gallery |
(33,971) |
(6,865) |
0 |
(40,836) |
|
|
Ashmont Community Facility |
(7,500) |
(1,500) |
0 |
(9,000) |
|
|
Bridge Replacement |
(601,972) |
0 |
(601,972) |
||
|
CBD Carparking Facilities |
(884,968) |
110,302 |
17,098 |
(757,568) |
|
|
CCTV |
(84,476) |
18,000 |
0 |
(66,476) |
|
|
Cemetery Perpetual |
(107,717) |
(133,730) |
16,519 |
(224,928) |
|
|
Cemetery |
(448,951) |
110,164 |
0 |
(338,787) |
|
|
Civic Theatre Operating |
(125,471) |
8,327 |
24,240 |
(92,904) |
|
|
Civic Theatre Technical Infrastructure |
(82,706) |
10,000 |
0 |
(72,706) |
|
|
Civil Projects |
(155,883) |
24,000 |
0 |
(131,883) |
|
|
Community Amenities |
(76,763) |
(214,928) |
0 |
(291,691) |
|
|
Community Works |
(86,412) |
(32,217) |
3,500 |
|
(115,129) |
|
Council Election |
(343,408) |
(83,163) |
0 |
(426,571) |
|
|
Economic Development |
(500,000) |
(80,000) |
0 |
(580,000) |
|
|
Emergency Events |
(191,160) |
(50,000) |
90,420 |
|
(150,740) |
|
Employee Leave Entitlements |
(3,585,224) |
|
0 |
|
(3,585,224) |
|
Environmental Conservation |
(115,206) |
|
(42,725) |
|
(157,931) |
|
Estella Community Centre |
(230,992) |
|
0 |
|
(230,992) |
|
Family Day Care |
(245,192) |
93,442 |
0 |
|
(151,750) |
|
Fit for the Future |
(1,785,102) |
266,703 |
698,874 |
43,000 |
(776,525) |
|
Generic Projects Saving |
(816,377) |
20,000 |
31,130 |
|
(765,248) |
|
Glenfield Community Centre |
(21,704) |
(2,000) |
0 |
|
(23,704) |
|
Grants Commission |
(5,256,259) |
|
5,256,259 |
|
0 |
|
Grassroots Cricket |
(70,992) |
|
0 |
|
(70,992) |
|
Gravel Pit Restoration |
(797,002) |
|
3,546 |
|
(793,456) |
RESERVES SUMMARY
|
|||||
|
30 SEPTEMBER 2019 |
|||||
|
|
CLOSING BALANCE 2018/19 |
ADOPTED RESERVE TRANSFERS 2019/20 |
BUDGET VARIATIONS APPROVED UP TO COUNCIL MEETING 23.09.19 |
PROPOSED CHANGES for Council Resolution |
REVISED BALANCE |
|
Gurwood Street Property |
(50,454) |
|
0 |
|
(50,454) |
|
Hampden Bridge |
(107,198) |
|
107,198 |
|
0 |
|
Information Services |
(775,938) |
(222,792) |
350,000 |
|
(648,730) |
|
Infrastructure Replacement |
(335,497) |
(30,192) |
0 |
|
(365,689) |
|
Insurance Variations |
(100,246) |
|
0 |
|
(100,246) |
|
Internal Loans |
(660,754) |
260,962 |
398,554 |
|
(1,238) |
|
Lake Albert Improvements |
(28,338) |
(21,515) |
4,021 |
|
(45,832) |
|
LEP Preparation |
(2,667) |
|
0 |
|
(2,667) |
|
Livestock Marketing Centre |
(3,311,635) |
972,792 |
402,954 |
|
(1,935,889) |
|
Museum Acquisitions |
(39,378) |
|
0 |
|
(39,378) |
|
Oasis Building Renewal |
(320,759) |
65,000 |
28,529 |
|
(227,230) |
|
Oasis Plant |
(1,239,132) |
857,486 |
6,937 |
|
(374,709) |
|
Office Equipment/Building Projects |
(159,030) |
|
0 |
|
(159,030) |
|
Parks & Recreation Projects |
(206,102) |
30,148 |
75,954 |
|
(100,000) |
|
Planning Legals |
0 |
(40,000) |
0 |
|
(40,000) |
|
Plant Replacement |
(3,550,033) |
660,253 |
1,055,919 |
|
(1,833,861) |
|
Playground Equipment Replacement |
(95,290) |
(165,727) |
0 |
|
(261,017) |
|
Project Carryovers |
(2,453,184) |
518,327 |
1,934,858 |
|
0 |
|
Public Art |
(198,922) |
30,300 |
80,594 |
|
(88,028) |
|
Robertson Oval Redevelopment |
(92,151) |
|
0 |
|
(92,151) |
|
Senior Citizens Centre |
(17,627) |
(2,000) |
0 |
|
(19,627) |
|
Sister Cities |
(46,328) |
(10,000) |
0 |
|
(56,328) |
|
Sporting Event Attraction |
(169,421) |
|
0 |
|
(169,421) |
|
Sporting Event Operational |
(100,000) |
|
0 |
|
(100,000) |
|
Stormwater Drainage |
(158,242) |
(100,000) |
0 |
|
(258,242) |
|
Strategic Real Property |
0 |
|
(395,000) |
|
(395,000) |
|
Street Lighting Replacement |
(56,549) |
|
0 |
|
(56,549) |
|
Subdivision Tree Planting |
(702,868) |
(20,000) |
0 |
|
(722,868) |
|
Sustainable Energy |
(527,244) |
389,333 |
37,732 |
|
(100,179) |
|
Unexpended External Loans |
(431,337) |
|
431,337 |
|
0 |
|
Workers Compensation |
(93,251) |
|
0 |
|
(93,251) |
|
Total Internally Restricted |
(33,127,305) |
2,706,471 |
10,625,040 |
43,000 |
(19,752,794) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Total Restricted |
(127,651,734) |
13,756,577 |
18,444,108 |
391,474 |
(95,059,574) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Total Unrestricted |
(5,725,794) |
0 |
0 |
0 |
(5,725,794) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Total Cash, Cash Equivalents and Investments |
(133,377,528) |
13,756,577 |
18,444,108 |
391,474 |
(100,785,368) |
|
CONSULTANCY & LEGAL EXPENSES BUDGET REVIEW STATEMENT |
|||||||
|
30 September 2019 |
|||||||
|
|
|
Approved Changes |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
BUDGET 2019/20 |
SEPTEMBER QTR BUDGET VARIATIONS APPROVED TO DATE |
REVISED BUDGET |
RECOMMENDED CHANGES |
PROJECTED YEAR END RESULT |
ACTUAL |
|
|
|
|
||||||
|
Consultancy Expenses |
192,903 |
7,017 |
199,920 |
0 |
199,920 |
66,301 |
|
|
|
|
||||||
|
Legal Expenses |
248,757 |
4,510 |
253,267 |
0 |
253,267 |
44,236 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
CONTRACTS REVIEW STATEMENT |
||||||
|
30 September 2019 |
||||||
|
Contract Number |
Contractor |
Contract |
Contract |
Start |
Duration of |
Budgeted |
|
PD39825 |
Wagga Trucks Hino |
Supply Truck Hino FE 1426 |
$145,452 |
9/09/2019 |
10 weeks |
Y |
|
Cambia Consulting Pty Ltd |
Asset management consulting |
$105,475 |
17/09/2019 |
15 weeks |
Y |
|
|
PD39806 |
Capital Construction Equipment Pty Ltd |
Supply skid steer loader |
$122,300 |
3/09/2019 |
10 weeks |
Y |
|
PE08116 |
GHD Pty Ltd |
Developer servicing plan |
$72,624 |
15/08/2019 |
15 weeks |
Y |
|
PE08355 |
Town & Country Asphalting Pty Ltd |
ATP Cycle way Red Hill Road |
$149,979 |
25/09/2019 |
2 weeks |
Y |
|
PS04642 |
Interflow Pty Ltd |
Culvert pipe reline Lockhart Road |
$105,791 |
15/08/2019 |
12 weeks |
Y |
Section 356 Financial Assistance Requests
Thirteen Section 356 financial assistance requests have been received for the 28 October 2019 Ordinary Council meeting, which are shown below for Council’s consideration:
1. Wagga Wagga Local Aboriginal Education Consultative Group (WLAECG) – Proud & Deadly Awards Ceremony $850.00
The Vice President of the Wagga Wagga Local Aboriginal Education Consultative Group (WLAECG) has requested in the attached letter Council’s consideration of a waiver for the hire fees for the use of the Civic Theatre on 26 November 2019 from 8.30 am to 3.00 pm for the holding of the annual Proud & Deadly Awards Ceremony.
The writer notes:
“The formal cultural ceremony is an inclusive and well respected Aboriginal community event, attended by local and surrounding Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander public school students (K-12), parents, caregivers, community families, teachers, principals, Directors and Wiradjuri Elders that celebrates student success in schools e.g. Academic, cultural, sporting, leadership, community contribution etc.
Due to the increasing number of award recipients and local community families supporting the cultural event each year, we desperately seek Wagga City Council support to continue to provide a community space larger enough to facilitate the awards ceremony in a central location, ideally the Wagga Wagga Civic Theatre, as we would need to seat at least 450 people.
In the past, this ceremony has been held at the Wagga Commercial Club and is divided separately into primary school awards and secondary school awards; due to the small space allocation and high numbers of students and families involved. However, this arrangement is far from practical now due to the popularity of the awards ceremony and we wish to celebrate student success together.
We seek financial support in terms of venue costs, equipment, fee waiver and promotion.”
Civic Theatre Officers advise that the associated costs for holding the above event are approximately $2,529.50, made up of venue hire $850.00; staffing costs $1,522.50; and technical support of $157.00.
It is proposed that Council support the above event by contributing the venue hire costs of $850.00 (Community Hire rate charge item 0546). It is noted that the applicable Commercial Hire rate would be $2,300.
The above request aligns with Council’s Strategic Plan “Community Place and Identity” – Objective: We are proud of where we live and our identity”
Council has not provided any financial assistance to the above group in the last 12 months.
2. Gunni Thakun Cultural Association $196.00
Gunni Thakun Cultural Association note in their attached letter;
“Gunni Thakun Cultural Association is an organisation of mainly men from across NSW and Eastern Austral who practice (and re-establish) Aboriginal Culture whilst following tradition Lore and Law. This includes language, story, dance, ceremony and implement making where and when appropriate. From the 1990s this has included public corroborees at venues across NSW.
This year’s venue will be the Marrambidya Wetlands with associated camping at Wiradjuri Reserve, alongside the Aboriginal Healing Place established in 2016 and the Wiradjuri Reserve Aboriginal Place declared in 2012. This space was chosen to help all Wagga Wagga Community people connect with these areas and to feel a part of the community in the spirit of enjoyment, openness, trust and learning. “
The above request aligns with Council’s Strategic Plan “Community Place and Identity” – Outcome: We are proud of where we live and our identity”
Council approved a grant of $5,000 as part of the 2019/20 Annual Grants Program Connected Rural and Urban Communities Category (Council Officer Report RP-1 Ordinary meeting of Council held 22 July 2019) to the Gunni Thakun Cultural Association to assist with the staging costs of the free public Corrobboree event.
The detailed budget submitted as part of the grant application from the Association did not factor in Council ground hire costs which they may not have been aware of at the time of their grant application.
3. Climate Rescue of Wagga Inc (CROW) $160.00
The Climate Rescue of Wagga (Inc) (CROW) group has requested in the attached letter Council’s consideration of a waiver for the hire fees for the use the amphitheatre for their “Global Climate Strike event which was held on the 20 September 2019.
Climate Rescue of Wagga Inc (CROW) note in their attached letter;
“The community of Wagga Wagga and surrounding towns have created a not for profit community event to support the Global Climate Strike Which is a worldwide event set up by students“
The above request aligns with Council’s Strategic Plan “The Environment
– Objective: We create a sustainable environment for future generations”
Council provided $1,047 financial assistance to the above group as part of the 2019/20 Annual Grants (Natural Environment Category) program to purchase Blower door test units to improve energy efficiency of homeowner’s houses by finding leaks and providing information on remedying the leaks.
Given the relatively small amount requested it is proposed that the request be funded from the Parks operating budget which can absorb this minor cost.
NSW Sports Federation Inc (Sport NSW) has requested in the attached letter Council’s consideration of a waiver for the hire fees for the use of Bolton Park Stadium and adjacent Ovals for the holding of the “Girls Get Active Event” on the 28 of October 2019.
Sport NSW note in their attached letter;
Girls Get Active days are open to all female high school students from years 7 – 11, irrespective of their athletic abilities.
The above request aligns with Council’s Strategic Plan “The Environment
– Objective: We promote a healthy Lifestyle”
Council has not provided any financial assistance to the above group in the last 12 months.
Given the relatively small amount requested it is proposed that the request be funded from the Parks and Oasis operating budgets which can absorb this minor cost.
5. Wagga Wagga Pink Stumps Committee $1,077.00
The Wagga Wagga Pink Stumps Committee has requested in the attached letter Council’s consideration of a waiver for the hire fees for the use of Mark Taylor Oval at Bolton Park on Sunday 27October 2019 to hold a cricket game to raise funds for the McGrath Foundation.
The Wagga Wagga Pink Stumps Committee note in their attached letter – which was updated to request additional assistance on the 8 October 2019 by the Committee;
“On the 27th October a Pink Stumps Day is being held at the Mark Taylor Oval at Bolton Park from 10.00 to 2.00pm.
We are writing to Council to seek waiver of the fees that we are going to be charged for holding this event including the cost of providing bins, along with drinking water and 3 portaloos. We are aware that there are bins at Robertson Oval and wonder if they could be moved to the Mark Taylor Oval for the day.
The Pink Stumps Day is a charity event to raise funds for the McGrath Foundation. As you may know the McGrath Foundation places breast care nurses in areas of need to help women and men through their breast cancer journey. From diagnosis right throughout treatment McGrath Breast Care Nurses are available without referral and free of charge. Currently there are 132 McGrath Breast Cares Nurses in communities throughout Australia and 70,710 families have been supported since 2005.
This is the first time that an event such as this has been staged in Wagga and we hope to make it a regular event. Local people of note as well as State Cricketers will be playing “
The above request aligns with Council’s Strategic Plan “Safe and Healthy – Objective: We have access to health and support services that cater for all our needs”
Council has not provided any financial assistance to the above group in the last 12
months.
The ground hire charges for Mark Taylor Oval is $95 (proposed to be funded from the Parks Operating budget). The cost of providing bins is approximately $200 proposed to be funded from the Solid Waste Operating budget. Portaloo hire is approximately $582 and Amenities Block cleaning $200 (ex GST) proposed to be funded from the Sewer operating budget which can absorb these minor costs. The Committee was referred to Riverina Water for assistance with their drinking water request.
6. Wagga Autism Support Group $90.00
The Wagga Autism Support Group has requested in the attached letter Council’s consideration of a waiver for the hire fees for the use of the Shakespearian Garden (Botanic Garden) on 19 October 2019 to celebrate Carers Week.
The Wagga Autism Support Group note in their attached letter;
“We do hold this event as a fundraising event but as a community building celebration “.
The above request aligns with Council’s Strategic Plan “Community Place and Identity” – Objective: We have opportunities to connect with others”
Council has not provided any financial assistance to the above group in the last 12 months.
Given the relatively small amount requested it is proposed that the request be funded from the Parks operating budget which can absorb this minor cost.
7. Yandarra Day Celebrations $95.00
The Riverina Medical & Dental Aboriginal Corporation has requested in the attached letter Council’s consideration of a waiver for the hire fees for the use of Jack Mission Oval on 10 November 2019 for the holding of the Yandarra event.
The Riverina Medical & Dental & Dental Aboriginal Corporation note in their attached letter;
“Riverina Medical & Dental Aboriginal Corporation will be hosting Yandarra Day which will be held on Sunday 10th November 2019.
Yandarra (Wiradjuri for “mixing together”) is a day where we focus on healthy lifestyle and strengthening our community relationships. And also, a family friendly event which celebrates Indigenous culture, education and health promotion.
We invite Government and Non-Government organisations to participate in the Yandarra Day Celebrations by providing stalls with educational information, health checks and promoting community programs. The event is strictly a drug and alcohol-free event and it involves in healthy eating, light exercise and activities for all ages.”
The above request aligns with Council’s Strategic Plan “Community Place and Identity” – Outcome: We are proud of where we live and our identity”
Council has not provided any financial assistance to the above group in the last 12 months.
Given the relatively small amount requested it is proposed that the request be funded from the Parks operating budget which can absorb this minor cost.
8. Multicultural Council of Wagga Wagga Inc (MCWW) $1,800.00
The Multicultural Council of Wagga Wagga Inc (MCWW) has requested in the attached letter Council’s consideration of a waiver for the hire fees for the use of Council Facilities for up to 20 events a year.
The MWCC note in their attached letter:
We have had arrangements in place which has allowed our organisation access free of charge for Council ran facilities being 10 use per year. As the communities continues to grow, we are now seeking the number of uses to be increased to 20 per year.
With the loss of the HSP the Multicultural Council are not in a financial position to cover venue hire on behalf of our communities, but as an organisation we are still committed to provide opportunities for people to value their culture and connect.”
Discussions were undertaken with Community Service staff who advised as follows in regard to the MCWW request:
“The Multicultural Council of Wagga Wagga (MCWW) have had a previous endorsement by Council to waive 10 uses of Council community facility fees over the period of 2014-2019 in order to support their settlement assistance program for newly arrived refugees and emerging cultural and linguistic diverse communities to settle in our City. The MCWW are now requesting a further period 2019-2023 of Council approved fee waivers with a request to increase this from 10 to 20 uses of Council community facilities. This increase is recognising the community growth in numbers and the loss of the Federal HSP funding to the MCWW, leaving this organisation with the inability to cover the venue hire on behalf of the communities they are supporting, (see attached MCWW letter). The cost of the waiver to MCWW for 20 uses is estimated $1,800 against Council’s current fees and charges schedule. The MCWW request aligns with Council’s CSP and provides an invaluable support program for families and communities to connect and settle in our City. “
It is noted that it is proposed in 2020/21 to require all Community groups to make application for financial assistance. It is therefore deemed appropriate that the requested increase in access to Council facilities be considered only for the current 2019/20 financial year.
The above request aligns with Council’s Strategic Plan “Community Place and Identity” – Outcome: We have opportunities to connect with others”
Council has provided the MCWW with access to stage 10 events at Council facilities in the last 12 months at no charge.
Given the relatively small cost of each MCWW event it is proposed that the respective Council Community Facility absorb the cost of the use of the facility for MCWW events.
9. Wagga Inter Church Council $2,200.00
The Wagga Inter Church Council has requested in their attached letter Council’s consideration to providing financial assistance for their staging of “Christmas Carols in the Park 2019” at the Victory Memorial Gardens on 21 December 2019.
The Wagga Inter Church Council note in their attached letter:
“We are starting to coordinate the Wagga Inter church Carols in the Park for 2019. Wagga Wagga City Council was a great help last year, Coming on board as a financial partner.
I was wondering if Wagga Wagga City Council would be interested in coming on board as a financial partner again this year. Last year’s contribution and assistance was vital to the success of the event, and our goal is to provide a special event for Christmas to the community of Wagga.
We had about 4000 people last year and we hoping to achieve the same this year.
This year’s event will occur on Saturday 21st December with setup commencing on Friday 20th December at the victory memorial gardens.”
The “Christmas Carols in the Park 2019” is a free event that provides an opportunity for community members to celebrate Christmas in a family friendly environment
The above request aligns with Council’s Strategic Plan “Community Place and Identity” – Outcome: We have opportunities to connect with others”
The adopted 2019/20 Combined Delivery Program and Operational Plan has allocated $2,200 for the Kurrajong Waratah Christmas Spectacular. Kurrajong Waratah are not staging a 2019 Christmas Spectacular at the Music Bowl and it is therefore proposed to reallocate these funds to the Inter Church Christmas Carols in the Park 2019.
Council provided the Wagga Inter Church Council financial assistance of $2,774 in the last 12 months i.e. contribution to the staging of the 2018 Christmas Carols in the Park.
Council in 2018 absorbed the costs of additional general waste /recycling bins required for that Christmas Carol event. It is proposed that Council absorb the costs for the provision of additional general waste/recycling bins required for the 2019 event, which would be funded from Council’s Waste Services Business Unit which has the capacity to absorb this cost. The estimated cost of the general waste/recycling bins is approximately $400.
10. Vigil in memory of Mhelody Polan Bruno $95.00
Katielle Dyall-Smith on behalf of Wagga Community members has requested Council’s consideration to the waiver of the hire fees for the Victory Memorial Gardens for the Vigil held on the 7 October 2019 in memory of Mhelody Polan Bruno.
Katielle notes in her attached letter:
“If at all possible it would be greatly appreciated if the booking fee could be waived, we are not an organisation and as such have no funds to manage, from which we could pay the $95.00 fee. This event is a vigil and no one would be making a financial gain, in any form. Additionally we won't be accepting donations either.
A sincere thank you for your time and consideration on this matter.”
The above request aligns with Council’s Strategic Plan “Community Place and Identity” – Outcome: We have opportunities to connect with others”
Given the relatively small amount requested it is proposed that the request be funded from the Parks operating budget which can absorb this minor cost.
11. Tarcutta Transport & Farming Museum Incorporated $873.12
The Tarcutta Transport and Farming Museum Inc have in their attached letter requested Council’s consideration to providing financial assistance for the Council lease fees for their Museum site in Tarcutta (Lot 7009 DP 1028847) located at the corner of Gresham Street and Prospect Street, Tarcutta.
The Committee is in the early stages of establishing a Transport & Farming Museum and advise that they are seeking further grants to establish the museum and until that time do not have any funds to pay Council’s annual rent charges.
The Committee note in their attached letter:
“The committee has been unable to earn any money at the site due to no toilet amenities available for public use and the inability to use the facility to earn the required funds. It has been out of use for the past almost two years.
We are waiting on the approval of a grant to enable us to develop the site further.
The committee has supplied a financial statement which indicates there are no funds available to pay Council fees.”
The above request aligns with Council’s Strategic Plan “Community Leadership and Collaboration” – Outcome: We are active community members ”
The current rental /lease fees outstanding from 24/07/2018 to 28/02/2020 is $873.12. It is proposed that the removal of this annual rental cost be absorbed by the Property Section Cost Centre which can absorb this relatively small amount.
Council has not provided any financial assistance to the above group in the last 12 months.
Budget
The Section 356 general fees and charges financial assistance budget for the 2019/20 financial year is $48,123.50, of which $39,907 is already committed in the adopted 2019/20 Delivery and Operational Plan.
It is proposed that financial assistance of $850.00 (Request 1) from the Section 356 unexpended 2019/20 budget and the remaining requests 2) to 11) be funded by the respective cost centre operating budgets given the relatively small amounts requested.
|
Section 356 Budget Summary |
|
|
Unallocated balance of S356 fee waiver financial assistance budget 2019/20 |
$3,848.50 |
|
1) Wagga Wagga Local Aboriginal Education Consultative Group (WLAECG) |
($850.00) |
|
2) Gunni Thakun Cultural Association - $196.00
|
Funded by Parks Cost Centre |
|
3) Climate Rescue of Wagga Inc (CROW) - $160.00 |
Funded by Parks Cost Centre |
|
4) NSW Sports Federation Inc (Sport NSW) - $348.00 |
Funded by Parks & Oasis Cost Centres) |
|
5) Wagga Wagga Pink Stumps Committee - $1,077.00 |
Funded by Parks, Waste & Sewer Operating Cost Centres |
|
6) Wagga Autism Support Group - $90.00 |
Funded by Parks Cost Centre |
|
7) Riverina Medical & Dental & Dental Aboriginal Corporation - $95.00 |
Funded by Parks Cost Centre |
|
8) Multicultural Council of Wagga Wagga Inc. (MCWW) - $1,800.00 (Access to Council Community Facilities up to 20 events at an average cost of $90.00 per event - for 2019/20 Financial year
|
Funded by respective Council Community facility operating budget |
|
9) Wagga Inter Church Council - $2,200.00 funded from proposed reallocation of $2,200.00 allocated to the Kurrajong Waratah Christmas Spectacular - Music Bowl which is not being held in 2019 and $400.00 Waste Bin provision for the event funded from the Waste Services operating budget. |
Fund by reallocation of existing S356 budget allocation and Council Waste Services Operating budget |
|
10) Vigil in memory of Mhelody Polan Bruno -$95.00 |
Funded by Parks Cost Centre |
|
11) Tarcutta Transport & Farming Incorporated - $873.12 |
Funded by Property Section Cost Centre |
|
Subtotal Fee Waivers included in this report – proposed to be funded from the Section 356 Budget |
($850.00) |
|
Balance of Section 356 fee waiver financial assistance budget for the remainder of the 2019/20 Financial Year |
$2,998.50 |
As noted earlier, it is proposed to fund Financial Assistance requests 2) to 11) via the respective Council Cost Centre nominated which can absorb these relatively minor hire charges.
Investment Summary as at 30 September 2019
In accordance with Regulation 212 of the Local Government (General) Regulation 2005, details of Wagga Wagga City Council’s external investments are outlined below:
|
Institution |
Rating |
Closing Balance |
Closing Balance |
September |
September |
Investment |
Maturity |
Term |
|
Short Term Deposits |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
AMP |
BBB+ |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
2.65% |
1.40% |
3/06/2019 |
2/12/2019 |
6 |
|
AMP |
BBB+ |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
2.80% |
0.70% |
17/05/2019 |
13/11/2019 |
6 |
|
AMP |
BBB+ |
1,000,000 |
0 |
0.00% |
0.00% |
6/03/2019 |
2/09/2019 |
6 |
|
AMP |
BBB+ |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
3.00% |
0.70% |
6/03/2019 |
2/12/2019 |
9 |
|
MyState |
BBB |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
2.75% |
0.70% |
1/04/2019 |
1/04/2020 |
12 |
|
Suncorp-Metway |
A+ |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
2.26% |
1.40% |
28/05/2019 |
28/11/2019 |
6 |
|
NAB |
AA- |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
1.67% |
0.70% |
28/08/2019 |
28/02/2020 |
6 |
|
ICBC |
A |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
1.67% |
0.70% |
29/08/2019 |
28/08/2020 |
12 |
|
NAB |
AA- |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
1.65% |
1.40% |
30/08/2019 |
6/03/2020 |
6 |
|
Macquarie Bank |
A |
0 |
2,000,000 |
1.75% |
1.40% |
2/09/2019 |
2/03/2020 |
6 |
|
NAB |
AA- |
0 |
1,000,000 |
1.70% |
0.70% |
10/09/2019 |
11/05/2020 |
8 |
|
Total Short Term Deposits |
|
12,000,000 |
14,000,000 |
2.16% |
9.80% |
|
|
|
|
At Call Accounts |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
NAB |
AA- |
687,343 |
149,403 |
1.00% |
0.10% |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
NAB |
AA- |
0 |
0 |
1.69% |
0.00% |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
Rabobank |
A+ |
0 |
0 |
0.00% |
0.00% |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
CBA |
AA- |
3,439,248 |
1,658,244 |
1.00% |
1.16% |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
CBA |
AA- |
15,374,736 |
15,393,261 |
1.60% |
10.77% |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
Total At Call Accounts |
|
19,501,327 |
17,200,909 |
1.54% |
12.04% |
|
|
|
|
Medium Term Deposits |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
RaboBank |
A+ |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
3.16% |
0.70% |
5/06/2017 |
6/06/2022 |
60 |
|
ME Bank |
BBB |
2,000,000 |
0 |
0.00% |
0.00% |
2/09/2014 |
2/09/2019 |
60 |
|
Rabobank |
A+ |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
4.10% |
0.70% |
5/12/2014 |
5/12/2019 |
60 |
|
BOQ |
BBB+ |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
3.10% |
1.40% |
7/07/2017 |
7/07/2020 |
36 |
|
AMP |
BBB+ |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
3.00% |
1.40% |
2/08/2018 |
3/02/2020 |
18 |
|
Rabobank |
A+ |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
3.20% |
0.70% |
25/08/2016 |
25/08/2021 |
60 |
|
Westpac |
AA- |
3,000,000 |
3,000,000 |
2.11% |
2.10% |
10/03/2017 |
10/03/2022 |
60 |
|
Auswide |
BBB |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
2.95% |
1.40% |
5/10/2018 |
6/10/2020 |
24 |
|
ING Bank |
A |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
2.92% |
0.70% |
16/10/2017 |
16/10/2019 |
24 |
|
ING Bank |
A |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
2.92% |
1.40% |
6/11/2017 |
6/11/2019 |
24 |
|
BOQ |
BBB+ |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
3.35% |
1.40% |
3/01/2018 |
4/01/2022 |
48 |
|
ING Bank |
A |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
2.80% |
0.70% |
5/01/2018 |
6/01/2020 |
24 |
|
Police Credit Union |
NR |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
3.05% |
1.40% |
29/10/2018 |
29/10/2020 |
24 |
|
Australian Military Bank |
NR |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
2.95% |
0.70% |
29/05/2018 |
29/05/2020 |
24 |
|
BOQ |
BBB+ |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
3.50% |
0.70% |
1/06/2018 |
1/06/2022 |
48 |
|
Westpac |
AA- |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
3.02% |
1.40% |
28/06/2018 |
28/06/2021 |
36 |
|
Westpac |
AA- |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
2.88% |
1.40% |
28/06/2018 |
29/06/2020 |
24 |
|
ING Bank |
A |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
2.86% |
1.40% |
16/08/2018 |
17/08/2020 |
24 |
|
BOQ |
BBB+ |
3,000,000 |
3,000,000 |
3.25% |
2.10% |
28/08/2018 |
29/08/2022 |
48 |
|
ING Bank |
A |
3,000,000 |
3,000,000 |
2.85% |
2.10% |
30/08/2018 |
14/09/2020 |
24 |
|
P&N Bank |
BBB |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
3.10% |
0.70% |
16/10/2018 |
18/10/2021 |
36 |
|
Institution |
Rating |
Closing Balance |
Closing Balance |
September |
September |
Investment |
Maturity |
Term |
|
Westpac |
AA- |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
3.05% |
1.40% |
13/11/2018 |
15/11/2021 |
36 |
|
Police Credit Union |
NR |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
3.07% |
0.70% |
20/11/2018 |
20/11/2020 |
24 |
|
P&N Bank |
BBB |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
3.30% |
0.70% |
20/11/2018 |
21/11/2022 |
48 |
|
ING Bank |
A |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
2.93% |
1.40% |
29/11/2018 |
30/11/2020 |
24 |
|
NAB |
AA- |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
3.01% |
1.40% |
30/11/2018 |
30/11/2021 |
36 |
|
Bendigo-Adelaide |
BBB+ |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
3.25% |
0.70% |
30/11/2018 |
30/11/2022 |
48 |
|
CUA |
BBB |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
3.02% |
1.40% |
5/12/2018 |
7/12/2020 |
24 |
|
Newcastle Permanent |
BBB |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
3.05% |
1.40% |
8/02/2019 |
8/02/2022 |
36 |
|
ING Bank |
A |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
2.82% |
0.70% |
22/02/2019 |
22/02/2021 |
24 |
|
Newcastle Permanent |
BBB |
2,000,000 |
2,000,000 |
2.70% |
1.40% |
23/04/2019 |
26/04/2022 |
36 |
|
BoQ |
BBB+ |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
2.40% |
0.70% |
22/05/2019 |
23/05/2022 |
36 |
|
BoQ |
BBB+ |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
2.15% |
0.70% |
8/07/2019 |
10/07/2023 |
48 |
|
Judo Bank |
NR |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
2.30% |
0.70% |
16/07/2019 |
16/07/2021 |
24 |
|
Auswide |
BBB |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
1.95% |
0.70% |
12/08/2019 |
12/08/2022 |
36 |
|
Judo Bank |
NR |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
2.15% |
0.70% |
20/08/2019 |
19/08/2021 |
24 |
|
Australian Military Bank |
NR |
1,000,000 |
1,000,000 |
1.76% |
0.70% |
20/08/2019 |
20/08/2021 |
24 |
|
Judo Bank |
NR |
0 |
1,000,000 |
1.90% |
0.70% |
10/09/2019 |
9/09/2022 |
36 |
|
Total Medium Term Deposits |
|
59,000,000 |
58,000,000 |
2.88% |
40.60% |
|
|
|
|
Floating Rate Notes - Senior Debt |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
AMP |
BBB+ |
1,003,305 |
1,004,028 |
BBSW + 135 |
0.70% |
24/05/2016 |
24/05/2021 |
60 |
|
Teachers Mutual |
BBB |
1,505,185 |
1,507,279 |
BBSW + 140 |
1.06% |
28/10/2016 |
28/10/2019 |
36 |
|
Heritage Bank |
BBB+ |
604,095 |
0 |
0.00% |
0.00% |
4/05/2017 |
4/05/2020 |
36 |
|
Teachers Mutual |
BBB |
1,011,748 |
0 |
0.00% |
0.00% |
29/06/2017 |
29/06/2020 |
36 |
|
Suncorp-Metway |
A+ |
1,009,152 |
1,010,344 |
BBSW + 97 |
0.71% |
16/08/2017 |
16/08/2022 |
60 |
|
Westpac |
AA- |
2,016,675 |
2,019,276 |
BBSW + 81 |
1.41% |
30/10/2017 |
27/10/2022 |
60 |
|
ME Bank |
BBB |
1,510,802 |
1,512,964 |
BBSW + 125 |
1.06% |
9/11/2017 |
9/11/2020 |
36 |
|
NAB |
AA- |
2,012,224 |
2,014,126 |
BBSW + 80 |
1.41% |
10/11/2017 |
10/02/2023 |
63 |
|
ANZ |
AA- |
1,510,570 |
1,512,332 |
BBSW + 77 |
1.06% |
18/01/2018 |
18/01/2023 |
60 |
|
Bendigo-Adelaide |
BBB+ |
504,575 |
505,244 |
BBSW + 105 |
0.35% |
25/01/2018 |
25/01/2023 |
60 |
|
Newcastle Permanent |
BBB |
1,517,678 |
1,519,470 |
BBSW + 140 |
1.06% |
6/02/2018 |
6/02/2023 |
60 |
|
Westpac |
AA- |
2,022,207 |
2,013,141 |
BBSW + 83 |
1.41% |
6/03/2018 |
6/03/2023 |
60 |
|
UBS |
A+ |
2,017,133 |
2,007,970 |
BBSW + 90 |
1.41% |
8/03/2018 |
8/03/2023 |
60 |
|
Heritage Bank |
BBB+ |
1,415,763 |
1,409,554 |
BBSW + 123 |
0.99% |
29/03/2018 |
29/03/2021 |
36 |
|
ME Bank |
BBB |
1,615,550 |
1,618,011 |
BBSW + 127 |
1.13% |
17/04/2018 |
16/04/2021 |
36 |
|
ANZ |
AA- |
2,019,080 |
2,019,929 |
BBSW + 93 |
1.41% |
9/05/2018 |
9/05/2023 |
60 |
|
NAB |
AA- |
2,017,763 |
2,019,631 |
BBSW + 90 |
1.41% |
16/05/2018 |
16/05/2023 |
60 |
|
CBA |
AA- |
2,019,669 |
2,021,486 |
BBSW + 93 |
1.41% |
16/08/2018 |
16/08/2023 |
60 |
|
Bank Australia |
BBB |
754,072 |
755,368 |
BBSW + 130 |
0.53% |
30/08/2018 |
30/08/2021 |
36 |
|
CUA |
BBB |
609,122 |
606,149 |
BBSW + 125 |
0.42% |
6/09/2018 |
6/09/2021 |
36 |
|
AMP |
BBB+ |
1,505,283 |
1,497,973 |
BBSW + 108 |
1.05% |
10/09/2018 |
10/09/2021 |
36 |
|
NAB |
AA- |
2,026,107 |
2,017,405 |
BBSW + 93 |
1.41% |
26/09/2018 |
26/09/2023 |
60 |
|
Bendigo-Adelaide |
BBB+ |
1,008,943 |
1,010,403 |
BBSW + 101 |
0.71% |
19/10/2018 |
19/01/2022 |
39 |
|
CBA |
AA- |
3,061,885 |
3,064,123 |
BBSW + 113 |
2.14% |
11/01/2019 |
11/01/2024 |
60 |
|
Westpac |
AA- |
3,061,360 |
3,064,727 |
BBSW + 114 |
2.15% |
24/01/2019 |
24/04/2024 |
63 |
|
ANZ |
AA- |
2,543,035 |
2,544,741 |
BBSW + 110 |
1.78% |
8/02/2019 |
8/02/2024 |
60 |
|
NAB |
AA- |
2,028,005 |
2,028,843 |
BBSW + 104 |
1.42% |
26/02/2019 |
26/02/2024 |
60 |
|
Bank of China Australia |
A |
1,508,470 |
1,511,264 |
BBSW + 100 |
1.06% |
17/04/2019 |
17/10/2022 |
42 |
|
Westpac |
AA- |
2,515,184 |
2,517,851 |
BBSW + 88 |
1.76% |
16/05/2019 |
16/08/2024 |
63 |
|
Institution |
Rating |
Closing Balance |
Closing Balance |
September |
September |
Investment |
Maturity |
Term |
|
Suncorp-Metway |
A+ |
1,246,207 |
1,248,009 |
BBSW + 78 |
0.87% |
30/07/2019 |
30/07/2024 |
60 |
|
ANZ |
AA- |
2,000,935 |
2,001,990 |
BBSW + 77 |
1.40% |
29/08/2019 |
29/08/2024 |
60 |
|
HSBC |
AA- |
0 |
2,499,775 |
BBSW + 83 |
1.75% |
27/09/2019 |
27/09/2024 |
60 |
|
Total Floating Rate Notes - Senior Debt |
|
51,201,784 |
52,083,405 |
|
36.46% |
|
|
|
|
Managed Funds |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
NSW Tcorp |
NR |
1,564,536 |
1,581,778 |
1.10% |
1.11% |
17/03/2014 |
1/09/2024 |
125 |
|
Total Managed Funds |
|
1,564,536 |
1,581,778 |
1.10% |
1.11% |
|
|
|
|
TOTAL
CASH ASSETS, CASH |
|
143,267,647 |
142,866,092 |
|
100.00% |
|
|
|
|
LESS: RIVERINA REGIONAL LIBRARY (RRL) CASH AT BANK |
|
3,719,572 |
3,457,760 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
TOTAL
WWCC CASH ASSETS, CASH |
|
139,548,075 |
139,408,332 |
|
|
|
|
|
Council’s investment portfolio is dominated by Term Deposits, equating to approximately 50% of the portfolio across a broad range of counterparties. Cash equates to 12%, with Floating Rate Notes (FRNs) around 37% and growth funds around 1% of the portfolio.

Council’s investment portfolio is well diversified in complying assets across the entire credit spectrum. It is also well diversified from a rating perspective. Credit quality is diversified and is predominately invested amongst the investment grade Authorised Deposit-Taking Institutions (ADIs) (being BBB- or higher), with a smaller allocation to unrated ADIs.

All investments are within the defined Policy limits, as outlined in the Rating Allocation chart below:

Investment Portfolio Balance

Monthly Investment Movements
Redemptions/Sales – Council redeemed the following investment securities during September 2019:
|
Institution and Type |
Amount |
Investment Term |
Interest Rate |
Comments |
|
AMP Bank Term Deposit |
$1M |
6 months |
3.00% |
This term deposit was redeemed on maturity to allow for compliance with credit limits, following the AMP credit rating downgrade in August 2019. |
|
ME Bank Term Deposit |
$2M |
5 years |
4.28% |
This term deposit was redeemed on maturity and funds were reinvested in a new 6-month term deposit with Macquarie Bank (see below). |
|
Heritage Bank Floating Rate Note |
$600K |
3 years |
BBSW + 130bps |
This floating rate note was sold prior to maturity, with funds reinvested in a new 5-year HSBC floating rate note (see below). Council recognised a capital gain of $2,892. |
|
Teachers Mutual Bank Floating Rate Note |
$1M |
3 years |
BBSW + 142bps |
This floating rate note was sold prior to maturity, with funds reinvested in a new 5-year HSBC floating rate note (see below). Council recognised a capital gain of $6,550. |
New Investments – Council purchased the following investment securities during September 2019:
|
Institution and Type |
Amount |
Investment Term |
Interest Rate |
Comments |
|
Macquarie Bank Term Deposit |
$2M |
6 months |
1.75% |
The Macquarie Bank rate of 1.75% compared favourably to the rest of the market for this investment term. |
|
NAB Term Deposit |
$1M |
8 months |
1.70% |
The NAB rate of 1.70% compared favourably to the rest of the market for this investment. This term was chosen to fill a maturity gap within Council’s investment portfolio. |
|
Judo Bank Term Deposit |
$1M |
3 years |
1.90% |
The Judo Bank rate of 1.90% compared favourably to the rest of the market for this investment term. This term was chosen to fill a maturity gap within Council’s investment portfolio. |
|
HSBC Floating Rate Note |
$2.5M |
5 years |
BBSW + 83 |
Council’s independent Financial Advisor advised this Floating Rate Note represented good value. |
Rollovers – Council did not rollover any investment securities during September 2019.
Monthly Investment Performance
Interest/growth/capital gains for the month totalled $254,960, which compares unfavourably with the budget for the period of $298,250, underperforming budget for the month by $43,290.
Council’s underperformance against budget for September was mainly due to a negative movement for Councils Floating Rate Note portfolio. During the month of September trading margins for these investments widened, resulting in a reduction in the principal value of these investments. It is worth noting that a majority of Council’s floating rate notes are still trading at a premium and Council continues to receive its quarterly interest payments.

The longer-dated deposits in the portfolio, particularly those locked in above 3.00%, continue to anchor Council’s portfolio performance. It should be noted that Councils investment portfolio includes 17 investments yielding above 3.00%. As these investments mature, it is inevitable that they will be reinvested at lower prevailing rates. To reduce this reinvestment risk, Council staff and Council’s Independent Financial Advisor will continue to identify opportunities to lock in higher yielding investments as they become available.
In comparison to the AusBond Bank Bill Index* (1.74%), Council’s investment portfolio returned 2.40% (annualised) for September. Cash and At-Call accounts returned 1.44% (annualised) for this period. These funds are utilised for daily cash flow management and need to be available to meet operating and contractual payments as they fall due.
Over the past year, Councils investment portfolio has returned 2.91%, outperforming the AusBond Bank Bill index by 1.17%.

* The AusBond Bank Bill Index is the leading benchmark for the Australian fixed income market. It is interpolated from the RBA Cash rate, 1 month and 3 month Bank Bill Swap rates.
Report by Responsible Accounting Officer
I hereby certify that all of the above investments have been made in accordance with the provision of Section 625 of the Local Government Act 1993 and the regulations there under, and in accordance with the Investments Policy adopted by Council on 29 April 2019.
Carolyn Rodney
Responsible Accounting Officer
Policy and Legislation
Budget variations are reported in accordance with Council’s POL 052 Budget Policy.
Investments are reported in accordance with Council’s POL 075 Investment Policy.
Local Government Act 1993
Section 625 - How may councils invest?
Local Government (General) Regulation 2005
Section 212 - Reports on council investments
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Leadership and Collaboration
Objective: We have strong leadership
Outcome: We are accountable and transparent
Risk Management Issues for Council
This report is a control mechanism that assists in addressing the following potential risks to Council:
· Loss of investment income or capital resulting from ongoing management of investments, especially during difficult economic times
· Failure to demonstrate to the community that its funds are being expended in an efficient and effective manner
Internal / External Consultation
All relevant areas within the Council have consulted with the Finance Division in relation to the budget variations listed in this report.
The Finance Division has consulted with relevant external parties to confirm Council’s investment portfolio balances.
|
1⇩. |
Section 356 Financial Assistance Request - Wagga Wagga Local Aboriginal Education Consultative Group (WLAECG) |
|
|
2⇩. |
Section 356 Financial Assistance Request - Gunni Thakun Cultural Association |
|
|
3⇩. |
Section 356 Financial Assistance request - Climate Rescue of Wagga Inc (CROW) |
|
|
4⇩. |
Section 356 Financial Assistance Request - Sports NSW |
|
|
5⇩. |
Section 356 Financial Assistance Request - Wagga Pink Stumps Committee |
|
|
6⇩. |
Section 356 Financial Assistance Request - Wagga Austism Support Group |
|
|
7⇩. |
Section 356 Financial Assistance Request - Riverina Medical & Dental Aboriginal Corporation |
|
|
8⇩. |
Yandarra Day - Sponsorship letter accompanying fee waiver request |
|
|
9⇩. |
Section 356 Financial Assistance Request - The Multicultural Council of Wagga Wagga Inc |
|
|
10⇩. |
Section 356 Financial Assistance Request - Wagga Inter Church Council |
|
|
11⇩. |
Section 356 Financial Assistance Request - Vigil Memorial Gardens |
|
|
12⇩. |
Section 356 Financial Assistance Request - Tarcutta Transport & Farming Museum Inc |
|
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
RP-4 |
RP-4 LAKE ALBERT ROAD REHABILITATION STAGE 2 - REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL FUNDING
Author: Sylvester Otieno
Director: Caroline Angel
|
Summary: |
This report outlines the intention and need for rehabilitation of Lake Albert Road between Stanley Street and Kooringal Road in 2019/20. |
|
That Council: a receive and note the contents of the report b approve the budget variations as detailed in the Financial Implications section of the report |
Report
Background
Lake Albert Road is in poor condition. The road surface has significant rutting, flushing, extensive fatigue cracking, potholes and has lost general profile due to deformation.
The plan is to rehabilitate the road in stages over a number of years. The first stage between Fay Avenue and Baden Powell Drive was successfully completed in 2018/19. Stage 2 is the section between Stanley Street and Kooringal Road – Area 1 and Area 2 in Figure 1 attached.
This road rehabilitation project has been initiated to address three categories:
Freight: Lake Albert Road is a significant Arterial that supports heavy vehicle traffic and associated freight throughout the city. Recent traffic counts reveal Heavy Vehicle of 10% of all vehicles. Due to city growth and increasing traffic, current roadway is failing under stress of the increasing demand of traffic and heavy vehicles.
Commuter: Lake Albert Road forms a significant four lane arterial corridor linking southern suburbs to the central Wagga district. Recent traffic counts have recorded five-day average annual daily traffic of 13,621 vehicles per day. (10% of which is heavy freight as indicated above.)
The current surface is undulating and rough and is displeasing to travel for motorists and cyclists.
Safety: Project will address safety issues as follows:
· Improve surface profile
· Address potholing (safety issue all motorists)
· Provide increased skid resistance by addressing flushed areas and rutting
· Construction of a new pavement addresses potholing, which means Operations staff are not required to work amongst live traffic to action defects
· Improved roadway and line marking in proximity to multiple schools and businesses
Amenity: The road passes near schools, a church and residences. The AC pavement will drastically minimize the current high noise pollution impacts on the above establishments.
The Problem
Total funds required is $1,668,450 if Area 1 and 2 are completed this financial year, and $1,756,150 if the work is staged over two financial years.
The funds allocated for Urban Asphalt in 2019/20 and 2020/21 are $818,439 and $851,852 respectively. The 2019/20 allocation is sufficient for only Area 2.
There is merit in completing Areas 1 and 2 this financial year. Apart from potential savings, it will also minimise disruption to traffic and residents.

Figure 1 – Location Map for Stage 2
Financial Implications
Council officers are recommending to complete the project in the 2019/20 financial year at a cost of $1,668,450. The proposed funding sources for the project are:
$818,439 - Urban Asphalt budget (GPR recurrent budget)
$850,011 - Fit for the Future Reserve
Policy and Legislation
Roads Act 1993
Work, Health and Safety Act 2011
Link to Strategic Plan
The Environment
Objective: Create and maintain a functional, attractive and health promoting built environment
Outcome: We look after and maintain our community assets
Risk Management Issues for Council
· Operational risks include weather delays, unforeseen services and potentially poor ground conditions which could ultimately contribute to delays and increased costs associated with delivering the project.
· Legal risks Council include Council being held liable for any damages to underground infrastructure
· WHS risks will be managed on site.
· Traffic risks will be managed using an elaborate TMP, work at night and diversions.
· Noise impacts on sleeping residents will need to be managed accordingly.
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
RP-5 |
RP-5 DRAFT NEW POLICY - POL118 - ROADSIDE MEMORIALS POLICY
Author: Sylvester Otieno
Director: Caroline Angel
|
Summary: |
Council have previously never had a formal policy on roadside memorials. An adopted Council Policy will ensure that the community is aware of the processes and procedures that are required for the installation of a roadside memorial.
POL 0118 Roadside Memorials Policy has been drafted and is being presented to Council for endorsement to go on public exhibition |
|
That Council: a endorse the draft POL 118 Roadside Memorials Policy, that is to be placed on public exhibition for a period of 28 days from 29 October 2019 to 26 November 2019 and invites public submissions on the policy during this time. b receive a further report following the public exhibition and submission period i addressing any submissions made in respect of the proposed policy ii proposing adoption of the new policy unless there are any recommended amendments deemed to be substantial and requiring a further public exhibition period |
Report
Councils Draft Roadside Memorials Policy (POL118) has been developed in response to a formal request that was received from a family to install a roadside memorial for their son, at an intersection in Wagga Wagga.
Draft POL118 has been developed to provide guidance for Councils Operational staff, families and the community on the installation and removal of roadside memorials or tributes along Council’s roadsides.
This policy applies to all roads and public spaces under the care and control of Council. It does not apply to the Olympic, Hume or Sturt Highways.
Financial Implications
N/A
Policy and Legislation
· POL 008 – Activities on Public Road Reserve Policy
· POL012 – Enforcement and Prosecution Policy
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Leadership and Collaboration
Objective: We are informed and involved in decision making
Outcome: Everyone in our community feels they have been heard and understood
Risk Management Issues for Council
If implemented, the draft policy would address the following risks:
· Distraction of drivers caused by non-compliant roadside memorials,
· Accidents during placement of and visits to memorials,
· Risk of Council being regarded as uncompassionate towards grieving residents,
· Poor visual amenity caused by non-compliant memorials.
Internal / External Consultation
Internal consultation has occurred with Council’s Corporate Review Committee and Council’s Executive Team.
A Councillor Workshop was held on 30 September 2019 with the following Councillors in attendance:
· Councillor Y Braid
· Councillor D Hayes
· Councillor V Keenan
· Councillor R Kendall
· Councillor T Koschel
· Councillor K Pascoe
· Councillor D Tout
|
1⇩. |
Draft POL118 Roadside Memorials Policy |
|
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
RP-6 |
RP-6 Official invitation to attend 4th Kunming International Sister City Seminar
Author: Scott Gray
General Manager: Peter Thompson
|
Summary: |
A letter of invitation has been received for a delegation from Wagga Wagga to attend the 4th Kunming International Sister City Seminar, in Kunming from the 2-5 December 2019. This report outlines the intended outcomes from the seminar and proposes that the Mayor and General Manager lead a delegation from Wagga Wagga that includes invited educational experts. |
|
That Council: a appoint the Mayor and General Manager to lead a delegation to attend the 4th Kunming International Sister City Seminar from the 2 December to 5 December 2019 b endorse paying all reasonable delegation related expenses for the Mayor and General Manager |
Report
On the 29 September 2019, Council received the attached correspondence from Council’s Sister City Kunming, with an invitation to lead a Wagga Wagga delegation (including educational experts) to attend the 4th Kunming International Sister City Seminar. The seminar is proposed to be held between the 2-5 December 2019. The seminar has an education theme with an objective to strengthen exchange and cooperation between Kunming and their international sister cities on basic education, senior education and vocational education.
During the seminar Kunming is hoping to achieve the following with each of their sister cities:
1. Launching the Declaration of Educational Cooperation between International Sister Cities.
2. Establishing the Cooperation Union between International Sister Cities
3. Establishing the Promotional Association of Vocational Education
4. Signing the Agreement of International Education Cooperation
Council has been in contact with Charles Sturt University and the Riverina Institute of TAFE to attend this seminar. At the time of writing this report Charles Sturt University have advised that Associate Professor, Mark Frost, Head of School, Management and Marketing will be attending the seminar and the Riverina Institute of TAFE have expressed a desire to attend this seminar.
The City of Wagga Wagga’s Sister City relationship with the City of Kunming was established in 1988, with the city hosting a number of delegations since that time. Kunming is the capital of Yunnan province in China. It is a modern metropolis built around an ancient, previously walled city dating back 2400 years. Nearby stands the remarkable Kunming Stone Forest, a world-heritage listed limestone formation.
With China being Australia’s largest source of overseas students this visit provides further opportunities for Wagga Wagga to strengthen its existing relationships and seek additional prospects they may arise.
Council will cover all delegation related costs for the Mayor and General Manager. Costs covered include travel, gifts, meals and associated sundries. All other delegates are responsible for their own costs. Accommodation and transportation costs for delegates while in Kunming, will be borne by Kunming Municipal People’s Government.
Financial Implications
The total estimated costs for this visit are $3,200 (details to be confirmed once the visit is endorsed).
A financial year budget allocation of $7,500 exists for Sister City visits and activities, and with $2,428 expensed to date, leaves a budget remaining of $5,072 for the remainder of the 2019/20 financial year.
Policy and Legislation
· Sister City Community Committee Terms of Reference
· Payment of Expenses and Provision of Facilities to Councillors - POL 025
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Place and Identity
Objective: We have opportunities to connect with others
Outcome: Groups, programs and activities bring us together
Risk Management Issues for Council
N/A
Internal / External Consultation
Invitations have been offered to Charles Sturt University and the Riverina Institute of TAFE to attend this seminar as part of the official delegation.
|
1⇩. |
Invitation from Kunming |
|
|
2⇩. |
Schedule of the 4th Kunming International Sister City |
|
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
RP-7 |
RP-7 Douglas Aerospace Working Group
Author: Scott Gray
General Manager: Peter Thompson
|
Summary: |
The purpose of this Working Group is to oversee the development of a final report that details all of the processes, negotiations, costs and documentation leading up to, and post the sale of the Douglas Aerospace Hangar (DAH) to Regional Express (REX). |
|
That Council endorse the draft Douglas Aerospace Working Group Terms of Reference as tabled with this report. |
Report
At Council’s Ordinary Council Meeting held on Monday 9 September 2019 the following was resolved:
That Council:
a receives a final report that details all of the processes, negotiations, costs and documentation leading up to, and post the sale of the Douglas Aerospace Hangar (DAH) to Regional Express (REX)
b requests that the report be presented to an open Council Meeting in support of transparency and accountability
c receives a further report at the 8 October 2019 Council Meeting regarding the re-establishment of the Douglas Aerospace Review Committee (to include the original Council members for continuity) to oversee the process, which includes a terms of reference and membership for the Committee
This report is provided in response to part (c) of that resolution.
Council established a Douglas Aerospace Review Committee (DARC) in 2014 to provide oversight and advice in regards to solvency issues and other concerns surrounding Douglas Aerospace.
The initial DARC membership included the following:
· The Mayor, Councillor Rod Kendall;
· Deputy Mayor, Councillor Dallas Tout;
· Councillor Paul Funnell;
· Councillor Julian McLaren;
· Councillor Kerry Pascoe;
· Chair Audit and Risk Committee; and
· Manager Internal Audit Services.
To maintain continuity where possible, the attached Terms of Reference recommends the following membership for the new working group:
· The Mayor, Councillor Greg Conkey
· Deputy Mayor, Councillor Dallas Tout;
· Councillor Rod Kendall;
· Councillor Paul Funnell;
· Councillor Kerry Pascoe; and
· General Manager, Peter Thompson.
Financial Implications
At this stage, the detailed report will be development utilising existing internal resources.
Policy and Legislation
N/A
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Leadership and Collaboration
Objective: We have strong leadership
Outcome: We are accountable and transparent
Risk Management Issues for Council
There are no identified risk management issues. The working group will follow Council’s code of conduct and where appropriate other relevant Council policies.
Internal / External Consultation
Councillor Funnell was consulted during the development of the draft TOR.
|
1⇩. |
Douglas Aerospace Working Group - Terms of Reference |
|
RP-8 COUNCIL MEETING DATES JANUARY 2020 to DECEMBER 2020
Author: Ingrid Hensley
General Manager: Peter Thompson
|
Analysis: |
Council is required under Section 365 of the Local Government Act 1993 to meet at least 10 times each year, each time in a different month. The report provides a schedule for the continuation of two meetings per month according to the adopted position of Council. |
|
That Council endorse the schedule of Ordinary Council meetings for the period January 2020 to December 2020 as outlined in the report. |
Report
Council, at the 26 November 2018 Council Meeting, adopted meeting dates up to and including December 2019. This report provides a schedule of meeting dates for 2020. In accordance with established practice, Council Meetings are generally scheduled for the second and fourth Monday of each month.
Council meeting dates
Outlined below are the proposed Ordinary Council Meeting dates for the period January 2020 to December 2020:
· Monday, 20 January 2020
· Monday, 10 February 2020
· Monday, 24 February 2020
· Monday, 16 March 2020 (Wagga Wagga Borough Council – Sesquicentennial Anniversary)
· Monday, 30 March 2020 (5 Mondays in March)
· Tuesday, 14 April 2020 (Monday, 13 April 2020 is Easter Monday)
· Monday, 27 April 2020
· Monday, 11 May 2020
· Monday, 25 May 2020
· Monday, 15 June 2020
· Monday, 29 June 2020
· Monday, 13 July 2020
· Monday, 27 July 2020
· Monday, 10 August 2020
· Monday, 24 August 2020
· Monday, 28 September 2020
· Monday, 12 October 2020
· Monday, 26 October 2020
· Monday, 9 November 2020
· Monday, 23 November 2020
· Monday, 14 December 2020
Notes:
· 16 March 2020 - Sesquicentennial Anniversary
· NSW Local Government Elections are on 12 September 2020
· The date for the December meeting has been brought forward to accommodate for the Christmas break.
· Commencement time for Council Meetings is generally 6.00pm.
A report will be prepared for the November 2020 Council Meeting, which will propose dates for Council Meetings for January 2021 to December 2021.
In addition to the schedule of meetings set out above, the Local Government Act 1993 and Council’s adopted Code of Meeting Practice provides the ability for Extraordinary Meetings of the Council in accordance with prescribed provisions.
The recommendation makes provision for the General Manager, in consultation with the Mayor, to make a decision on the change of a date and/or time for a Council meeting. This will enable, where appropriate, changes to be made in a timely manner without the requirement for a report to Council.
Financial Implications
N/A
Policy and Legislation
N/A
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Leadership and Collaboration
Objective: We have strong leadership
Outcome: We plan long term
Risk Management Issues for Council
N/A
Internal / External Consultation
N/A
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
RP-9 |
RP-9 Mobile Food Vendor - Policy & Fee Exhibition
Author: Dominic Kennedy
Director: Michael Keys
|
Summary: |
This report seeks the adoption of the Mobile Food Vendor – Trading in Public Places (POL 062) policy and the modified fee schedule following the public exhibition period. |
|
That Council: a note that there were no public submissions received during the exhibition period of the draft Mobile Food Vendor – Trading in Public Places policy (POL 062) b adopt the Mobile Food Vendor – Trading in Public Places policy (POL 062) c adopt the amended (0924) Fees and Charges for 2019/20 |
Report
At the 12 August Ordinary Council meeting, the Mobile Food Vendor - Trading in Public Places policy (POL 062) and amended fees were endorsed and required to be placed on public exhibition. From 13/8/19 until 9/10/2019 the documents were made available for public viewing and comment.
Submissions
No public submissions were received by Council during the exhibition period.
A copy of the Mobile Food Vendor - Trading in Public Places policy (POL 062) is attached and the relevant fees and charges that will be amended are noted in the following table.
|
Item Number |
Fee and Charge Description |
Pricing Policy ID |
Basis |
2018/19 Fee (exclusive of GST) |
GST |
2019/20 Fee (inclusive of GST) |
|
0924 |
Part F(7) – Use a standing vehicle or any article for the purpose of selling any article in a public place (Fee waived for charitable organisations) |
C |
Each |
$145.00 |
$0.00 |
$350.00 |
If the policy and fee amendment are approved, Council staff will make all required documentation available through Council’s website and begin accepting applications from mobile food vendors. Potential vendors will be contacted about the opportunity through email with the intent of having up to 10 vendors operating under the program before Christmas.
Financial Implications
N/A
Policy and Legislation
The following documents are related to the Policy:
· Local Government Act 1993
· Local Government (General) Regulation 2005
· Food Act 2003
· Food Regulation 2010
· Roads Act 1993
· Roads Regulation 2008
· Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979
· Mobile Food Vending Vehicles – Operation, construction and food handling guidelines, August 2009 (available on the NSW Government Food website http://www.foodauthority.nsw.gov.au/)
· DLG Street Vending Control Guidelines
Link to Strategic Plan
Growing Economy
Objective: We are a hub for activity
Outcome: We have vibrant precincts
Risk Management Issues for Council
Community safety – ensuring customers are safe when accessing food options that could be in high vehicle traffic areas.
Food safety – ensuring mobile food vehicle vendors are abiding by all required food handling requirements
Competitive risk – providing clear direction around operating locations to ensure fair competition with brick & mortar establishments.
Opportunity for new business – providing an avenue for entrepreneurs to start and grow their business.
Internal / External Consultation
If the policy and amended fee schedule is adopted, Council staff will finalise application materials and notify stakeholders of opportunity.
|
|
|
Media |
Community Engagement |
Digital |
|||||||||||||
|
Rates notices insert |
Direct mail |
Letterbox drop |
Council news story |
Council News advert |
Media releases |
TV/radio advertising |
One-on-one meetings |
Your Say website |
Community meetings |
Stakeholder workshops |
Drop-in sessions |
Surveys and feedback forms |
Social media |
Email newsletters |
Website |
Digital advertising |
|
|
TIER |
|||||||||||||||||
|
Involve |
|
|
|
x |
|
|
|
|
|
x |
x |
||||||
|
1⇩. |
Mobile Food Vendor - Trading in Public Places policy |
|
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
RP-10 |
RP-10 DRAFT COMPLAINT HANDLING POLICY (POL 103)
Author: Ingrid Hensley
General Manager: Peter Thompson
|
Summary: |
Amendments have been made to POL 105 Complaint Handling Policy requiring the endorsement of Council. |
|
That Council: a endorse the draft Complaint Handling Policy (POL 103), that is to be placed on public exhibition for a period of 28 days from 29 October 2019 to 27 November 2019 and invite public submissions until the 10 December 2019 on the draft Policy b receive a further report following the public exhibition and submission period: i addressing any submissions made in respect of the proposed POL 103 Complaint Handling Policy b ii proposing adopting of the Policy unless there are any recommended amendments deemed to be substantial and requiring a further public exhibition period |
Report
A review of Council’s Complaint Handling Policy has been undertaken in conjunction with recent ongoing process improvements such as on-line complaints, identified responsibilities and system improvements for monitoring and reporting. The Complaints Handling Policy has been amended to ensure clarity and consistency across the complaint handling process.
As part of the review, consideration was given to methods available to lodge a complaint, clear timeframes to support actioning, Council’s and the complainant’s obligations, explanation of timeframes relating to the monitoring and reporting of complaints, all with reference to the NSW Ombudsman’s guidance material for complaint handling in local government.
To allow community feedback on the Policy, it is recommended that the Policy be placed on public exhibition for 28 days from 29 October to 27 November 2019 and invite public submission until 10 December 2019.
Financial Implications
N/A
Policy and Legislation
Complaint Handling Policy (POL 103)
Local Government Act 1993 (NSW)
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Leadership and Collaboration
Objective: We have strong leadership
Outcome: We are accountable and transparent
Risk Management Issues for Council
Council policies are essential to ensure transparent legal, fair and consistent decision-making across the Council. They support Council in achieving its corporate objectives and provide a critical guide for staff, Councillors and other stakeholders. In the absence of effective policies there is a greater risk of inconsistency, confusion and inefficiency.
Internal / External Consultation
The draft Complaint Handling Policy (POL 105) has been internally reviewed by Council staff and endorsed with no changes by the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee at its meeting on 15 August 2019.
If Council resolve to place the draft Policy on public exhibition, the following methods of consulting will be utilised:
|
|
|
Media |
Community Engagement |
Digital |
|||||||||||||
|
Rates notices insert |
Direct mail |
Letterbox drop |
Council news story |
Council News advert |
Media releases |
TV/radio advertising |
One-on-one meetings |
Your Say website |
Community meetings |
Stakeholder workshops |
Drop-in sessions |
Surveys and feedback forms |
Social media |
Email newsletters |
Website |
Digital advertising |
|
|
TIER |
|||||||||||||||||
|
Consult |
|
|
|
x |
|
|
x |
|
|
|
|
x |
|
||||
|
1⇩. |
Draft Complaint Handling Policy (POL 103) |
|
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
RP-11 |
RP-11 Response to Questions/Business with Notice
Author: Scott Gray
General Manager: Peter Thompson
|
Summary: |
This report is to provide responses to Questions/Business with Notice arising from previous Ordinary Council Meetings. |
|
That Council receive and note the report. |
Report
The following is in response to Questions/Business raised at the 8 October 2019 Ordinary Council meeting.
|
Councillor D Hayes requested advice if Council were planning to upgrade the playground in Oura in the future. |
|
Response provided by the Regional Activation Directorate
Within the Playground Strategy it is proposed that the playground at the Oura recreation reserve be upgraded in 2025/26. However, there is an action within the Recreation, Open Space and Community Strategy that identifies additional improvements for this park including the provision of a BMX pump track or like facility in the future. This is currently unfunded however was recently included in a grant application for funding through the Stronger Country Communities Fund. |
Financial Implications
N/A
Policy and Legislation
Code of Meeting Practice
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Leadership and Collaboration
Objective: We have strong leadership
Outcome: We have leaders that represent us
Risk Management Issues for Council
N/A
Internal / External Consultation
N/A
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
M-1 |
M-1 Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee Meeting Minutes 10 October 2019
Author: Ingrid Hensley
General Manager: Peter Thompson
|
Summary: |
The Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee is an advisory committee of Council. This Report seeks that Council endorse the recommendations made by the Committee at its August 2019 meeting. Those recommendations relate to the role of the Committee in providing independent assurance and assistance to Council on financial reporting, risk management, internal controls, governance, and internal and external audit and accountability responsibilities. |
|
That Council endorses the recommendations contained in the minutes of the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee Meeting held on 10 October 2019. |
Report
Report from the Chairperson
The Committee received Code of Conduct training session provided by the Manager Audit, Risk and Governance.
RP1: A New Risk Management and Internal Audit Framework for local councils in NSW – OLG Discussion Paper
The Committee discussed their views of the Framework. While it resolved that the ARIC would prepare its own response to OLG in due course, there was a strong indication that the Committee did not agree with a number of aspects outlined in the Discussion Paper.
These included not having Councillors as part of an ARIC – this is considered a retrograde approach, and the suggested increased remuneration for ARIC members. There was concern expressed regarding the transition timing, lack of clarity on how to ensure Council is across the work of an ARIC and the prequalification process.
RP2: ARIC Action Register
At its meeting of 15 August 2019, the Committee was advised that the NSW Audit Office was undertaking a Cyber Security audit. This audit was scheduled for the Internal Audit Workplan for 2019/2020 and it suggested that the scheduled internal audit be cancelled with the view that Council would work with the NSW Audit Office when it undertook its proposed Cyber Security audit. It was later discovered that the Cyber Security audit to be undertaken by the NSW Audit Office did not have a dedicated time frame for completion.
It was therefore requested by the Committee to have the Cyber Security audit reinstated to Council’s Internal Audit work program for the 2019/2020 period.
Resourcing for the Internal Audit Function remains of concern to the Committee and it was advised that the RTF for Provision of Internal Audit would close on Wednesday 16 October 2019 and recruitment action for a Chief Audit Executive would close on Friday 18 October 2019.
The Committee was further advised that it is not expected that there would be a resource available for Internal Audit until February 2020. This is more than twelve months after the resignation of the CAE in late 2018.
RP3: Risk and audit maturity assessment (RAMA) Draft Report.
The Committee received a presentation from Ms Lynne Ting (JLT) regarding the maturity of risk management and the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee. Risk management was assessed against the NSW Audit Office risk management tool and the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee was assessed against an IIA Audit Committee maturity assessment tool. In both assessments some recommendations for improvement were made within the draft report.
The Committee requested that an action plan to address suggested improvements from the RAMA be provided to them in early 2020.
RP4 and 5: Financial Statements
Preparation of financial statements is the responsibility of management and the Council, not the external auditors or the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee. The Committee’s responsibility is to make an advisory judgement on the financial statements and the systems and procedures used to create them.
The Director Finance advised the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee that the external audit of the 2018/2019 financial statements has been completed successfully and that there were no contentious financial reporting matters or material changes to be reported.
The Committee reviewed the key aspects of the financial statements and sought clarification of a number of issues. Matters discussed included:
· Changes to accounting standards
· Explanation of key movements in the net operating result for the year
· RFS assets and Crown Lands
· Financial performance indicators
· Asset valuation and impairment
· Contingent assets and liabilities
· Working capital, and
· Events since balance date.
As a result of these discussions and internal audit coverage during the year and past periods, the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee reached the conclusion that, in accordance with its charter:
· it was satisfied that the annual financial statements for the year ended 30 June 2019 comply with applicable Australian accounting standards and are supported by appropriate management sign-off on the statements and Council’s systems of internal controls;
· the proposed external audit opinion was supported by appropriate coverage and management had taken appropriate action on all material audit recommendations to date; and
· there were no other contentious financial reporting matters that the Committee considered should be reported to Council.
Council’s external auditors informed the Committee that (subject to final clearance of minor changes to the statements) the external audit report on the financial statements would be unqualified and that Council’s financial position is ‘sound’.
They also advised that they found no accounting policies or application of policies, other than was already disclosed in the statements, that needed to be brought to the attention of the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee.
The external auditors noted that the working papers and the level of co-operation provided during the audit were both professional and of high standard.
Marg Nicholls
Chair
Wagga Wagga City Council Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee
Financial Implications
Council has granted certain authorities to the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee within the scope of its role and responsibilities, as defined within its Charter. As an advisory committee to Council, the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee has no authority to action items that may have a budget and/or resource implication outside of this authority unless Council resolves to adopt the recommendations.
Policy and Legislation
Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee Charter
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Leadership and Collaboration
Objective: We have strong leadership
Outcome: We are accountable and transparent
Risk Management Issues for Council
The Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee assists Council by monitoring its risk exposure and determining if management systems have appropriate risk management processes in place
Internal / External Consultation
N/A
Attachments
|
1⇩. |
Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee Meeting Minutes 10 October 2019 |
|
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
M-2 |
M-2 TRAFFIC COMMITTEE - 12 SEPTEMBER 2019
Author: Bill Harvey
Director: Caroline Angel
|
Summary: |
The Local Traffic Committee met on 12 September 2019. At this meeting, Traffic Committee considered eight reports.
The Minutes of the meeting are attached for Councillors’ reference. |
|
That Council: a receive the minutes of the Traffic Committee Meeting held on 12 September 2019 b endorse the recommendations of the Traffic Committee |
Report
The table below provides a summary of each item’s risk and budget implications in particular:
|
No. |
ITEM |
UNMITIGATED RISK RATING |
ESTIMATED COST |
FUNDING SOURCE |
APPROVAL |
|
RP1 |
Alpine Classic Rally – On-Street Event |
Moderate |
Nil |
Event Organiser |
Approved under staff delegation |
|
RP2 |
Gears & Beers – On-Street Event |
High |
$2,500 |
Event Road Closure Budget |
Approved under staff delegation |
|
RP3 |
Lake Run & Ride – On-Street Event |
High |
$6,500 |
Event Road Closure Budget |
Approved under staff delegation |
|
RP4 |
Coleman St and Macleay St – Design of Proposed Intersection Treatment |
Moderate |
$2,000 |
Unfunded – proposed to be funded from the Design Forward Planning Budget |
Seeking Council endorsement |
|
RP5 |
Featherwood Rd – Proposed NO TRUCKS signs |
High |
$550 |
Lines and Signs Budget |
Seeking Council endorsement |
|
RP6 |
Fife Street Forest Hill – Proposal to Remove the Existing Taxi Zone |
Nil |
$100 |
Lines and Signs Budget |
Seeking Council endorsement |
|
RP7 |
Harris Road and Old Narrandera Rd – Temporary Intersection Design |
High |
Nil |
Developer Funded |
Seeking Council endorsement |
|
RP8 |
McKinnon St and Docker St – Installation of a Length of Double Unbroken Dividing Line in McKinnon St |
Moderate |
$250 |
Lines and Signs Budget |
Seeking Council endorsement |
Items of Particular Interest
RP-4 Coleman Street and Macleay Street – Design of Proposed Intersection Treatment
Traffic Committee members discussed options that would improve sight distance towards the east at this intersection. A proposal is made that a kerb bulb be designed that would provide additional protection for south bound drivers in Macleay Street so that they could move an additional three metres forward without fear of a collision from an east bound vehicle in Coleman Street. The existing GIVE WAY sign control should remain but with duplicated signs.
When a design has been prepared the matter should be reintroduced to Traffic Committee for confirmation of the nature of the design.
RP-6 Fife Street Forest Hill – Proposal to Remove the Existing Taxi Zone
At the July Traffic Committee meeting, members asked for the Taxi Co-operative to be canvassed on the need and use of a Taxi Zone in Fife Street. After that meeting a letter was sent to the Taxi Co-operative, asking for evidence in favour of keeping the zone. No reply has been received from the organisation. Business operators in the Forest Hill Shopping Centre have told Council Officers that the zone is never used by waiting Taxis. Pickups and drop offs are done in the shopping centre car park.
Financial Implications
The below table shows the budget required, and the current available budget for the proposed funding source for each of the items requiring funding:
|
Item |
Total Budget Required |
Proposed Funding Source |
Current Proposed Funding Source Budget |
Current Funding Source Expenditure including commitments as at 17/10/2019 |
Current Available Budget |
|
RP2, RP3,
|
$2,500 $6,500 $9,000
|
Event Road Closure |
$40,000 |
$13,528 |
$26,472 |
|
RP5, RP6, RP8 |
$550 $100 $250 $900 |
Lines & Signs |
$340,189 |
$111,142 |
$229,047 |
|
RP4
|
$2,000 |
Unfunded - Proposed to fund from the Design Forward Planning Budget |
$100,000 |
$26,799 |
$73,201 |
Policy and Legislation
N/A
Link to Strategic Plan
Safe and Healthy Community
Objective: We are safe
Outcome: We create safe spaces and places
Risk Management Issues for Council
N/A
Internal / External Consultation
The Traffic Committee consists of a Councillor, NSW Police, Transport for New South Wales and a representative of the Local Member. Representatives from Council’s Infrastructure and Planning staff provide advice to the Committee. Representatives from other agencies and entities may be invited to attend meetings as required.
|
1⇩. |
Taffic Commitee Minutes - 12 September 2019 |
|
|
Report submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
M-3 |
M-3 FLOODPLAIN RISK MANAGEMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE - MINUTES - 1 OCTOBER 2019
Author: Caroline Angel
|
Summary: |
The Floodplain Risk Management Advisory Committee met on 1 October 2019 |
|
That Council receive the minutes of the Floodplain Risk Management Advisory Committee Meeting held on 1 October 2019. |
Report
The Floodplain Risk Management Advisory Committee met on 1 October 2019. The minutes are attached for Councillors reference.
Financial Implications
N/A
Policy and Legislation
N/A
Link to Strategic Plan
Community Leadership and Collaboration
Objective: We are informed and involved in decision making
Outcome: Everyone in our community feels they have been heard and understood
Risk Management Issues for Council
N/A
Internal / External Consultation
N/A
|
1⇩. |
Floodplain Risk Management Commitee Minutes - 1 October 2019 |
|
Reports submitted to the Ordinary Meeting of Council to be held on Monday 28 October 2019.
|
Report submitted to the Confidential Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
CONF-1 |
CONF-1 RFT2019-33 STRENGTHENING AND WIDENING EUNONY BRIDGE
Author: Silas Darby
Director: Caroline Angel
This report is CONFIDENTIAL in accordance with Section 10A(2) of the Local Government Act 1993, which permits the meeting to be closed to the public for business relating to the following: -
(d) (i) commercial information of a confidential nature that would, if disclosed, prejudice the commercial position of the person who supplied it.
|
Report submitted to the Confidential Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
CONF-2 |
CONF-2 BOTANIC GARDENS RESTAURANT AND CAFE LEASE
Author: Dianne Wright
Director: Michael Keys
This report is CONFIDENTIAL in accordance with Section 10A(2) of the Local Government Act 1993, which permits the meeting to be closed to the public for business relating to the following: -
(d) (i) commercial information of a confidential nature that would, if disclosed, prejudice the commercial position of the person who supplied it.
|
Report submitted to the Confidential Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
CONF-3 |
CONF-3 Lake Albert Blue Green Algae Remediation (Extension of Trial)
Author: Rupesh Shah
Director: Caroline Angel
This report is CONFIDENTIAL in accordance with Section 10A(2) of the Local Government Act 1993, which permits the meeting to be closed to the public for business relating to the following: -
(d) (i) commercial information of a confidential nature that would, if disclosed, prejudice the commercial position of the person who supplied it.
|
Report submitted to the Confidential Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
CONF-4 |
CONF-4 RFT2020-08 ROAD STABILISATION PRODUCTS SUPPLY
Author: Sylvester Otieno
Director: Caroline Angel
This report is CONFIDENTIAL in accordance with Section 10A(2) of the Local Government Act 1993, which permits the meeting to be closed to the public for business relating to the following: -
(d) (i) commercial information of a confidential nature that would, if disclosed, prejudice the commercial position of the person who supplied it.
|
Report submitted to the Confidential Meeting of Council on Monday 28 October 2019 |
CONF-5 |
CONF-5 EXHIBITION CENTRE IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS
Author: Ben Creighton
Director: Michael Keys
This report is CONFIDENTIAL in accordance with Section 10A(2) of the Local Government Act 1993, which permits the meeting to be closed to the public for business relating to the following: -
(c) information that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with whom the Council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business.